Who won the debate?

Betty Jo Soldano, Jamestown, NY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:34:36 GMT

Although I am not a fan of Governor Palin, I was starting to feel sorry for her this past week.....BUT tonight got me off that train. It is frightening to think that there is a possibility of her becoming President. I thought she was disrespectful of Joe Biden and of Gwen by stating that she would not answer the questions the way the moderator wanted. She definitely was just reciting what has been pounded in her head in preparation. There is no way some of the words and thoughts that she spoke were her own. I am tired of her "cutesy" ways and the fact that she stated that she would like the VP to have more power really turned me off.

Who won the debate?

Eleanor Herndon, Greensboro NC — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:35:57 GMT

I was frightened by Palin's obvious memorization of set answers to questions she was going to answer whether they were asked or not. I was insulted by her "winking" at the camera so much and her "vacant" smile. What in the world would we be saying if Biden had done that. I was stunned by her inability to really hear Biden when he mentioned HIS FAMILY experience. She seems mean to me and actually sneered at a dignified senator. I was mad that she so easily will lie and I was disgusted that she wants to expand Cheney's role as veep. We are in a lot of trouble if this ticket wins.

I think Biden was clear, passionate and gracious to her. She did not deserve his good manners in retrospect. Eleanor Herndon, Greensboro, NC

Who won the debate?

Karen, Arlington, VA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:39:10 GMT

Palin dutifully recited some of her talking points, and changed the subject or refused to answer questions when they didn't fit. For that she gets credit. But can anyone say with a straight face that she won the debate, that she passed the "commander in chief" test (in the event something happens to McCain)?

Biden demonstrated his vast policy knowledge as well as his heart. He also showed a masterful sense of diplomacy. He'd be a great VP.

Who won the debate?

frank, new york, ny, — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:45:08 GMT

Definitions of Maverick.. Loose Cannon.. dissenter, enfant terrible..
Sounds like change alright. His way or the highway.
Just the person we need to unify America. Yeeehaw! Bring in the
motherless calf boys!

Who won the debate?

Gayle Gray — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:46:16 GMT

Biden won just by his restraint, I would've loved seeing him go after Madam Gov. Hate political evasion. Wouldn't walk across the street to see Palin.

Who won the debate?

Worried Voter — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:50:03 GMT

Sarah Palin was a frightening presence tonight. She was overbearing, frenetic, and grabbing for a power grab with her chilling remarks about disregarding the moderator and expanding the role of the Vice President. Her contentions about looking back are also frightening because wisdom says that those who don't learn from the past are doomed to repeat it.

Who won the debate?

Echo Garrett — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:50:29 GMT

Did Joe Biden really say "Barack Obama saw the glass as half empty and I saw it as half full?" He came across like a man that wanted to be President, not Vice President. Palin makes a fauxpas like that and the wild dogs tear into her...how are we NOT to think main stream media is biased?

Who won the debate?

AK, Wisconsin — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:50:44 GMT

McCain & Palin camp keep promising that McCain will work in a bipartisan way and it's such a joke! McCain is bitter, conrolling & dismissive if someone expresses a differing point of view, or dare question his campaign decisions. Palin surrounds herself with friends and dismisses anyone who disagrees with her. They are just like Bush & Cheaney!

Who won the debate?

Doug Farmingdale NY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:51:36 GMT

How could Palin win? She didn't answer the questions???? Where's Katie Couric when you need her. If the moderator had held her to answering the questions. it would have been like watching the katie Couric interview again. Let's start talking about her NOT ANSWERING THE QUESTIONS

Who won the debate?

Barbara Betts — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:52:05 GMT

Sarah Palin did a great job. She provides a fresh voice and a candidate whose main concern truly is America and the American people and not partisan politics as usual. If only we could get rid of many of our career politicians and their partisan agendas.
Also, it would be really refreshing to see news analysts who are really doing their job and not pushing their own politics.

Who won the debate?

SueB - Corpus Christi, TX — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:52:07 GMT

Buchanan please? Palin is ...Personable, young and exciting? Is that what makes a good vice presidential candidate? I think not! Were you watching the same debate I was ... she was all fluff no substance. Her answers were canned to questions not asked. Did she really call him OBiden?

I wanted to like her, I wanted thinking women everywhere to be proud to have a woman knocking on the glass ceiling. It didn't happen.

She doesn't appear to have a thought in her head that someone didn't put there. Obviously, McCain has no plan of change and if he does she could not state one part of it.

Why did Biden go back to the past, because as Sister Philomena taught in 9th grade History ... if you fail to examine the past you are destined to repeat it.

The definition of insane is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. I pray that none of us will be duped into continuing another 4 years of trickle down policies.

The economy is not strengthened by trickle down ... It never was. We are all strengthened when it bubbles up, no one wins until everyone wins.

As a small business owner for more than 30 years I can tell you that relatively few of us are pulling down more than $250,000 a year ... we'd be blessed in this economy to earn $100,000. When you are ... you are not longer a SMALL Business Owner.

What the Republicans are selling ... I am no longer buying.

Who won the debate?

Ann Turner, Oldsmar, FL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:53:00 GMT

I wish I had thought of Sarah Palin's strategy when I was in high school debate class--just cheat--don't answer the questions. If Gwen didn't have any authority to check that sort of gambit, why not just let both participants do a 45 minute stump speech.

Biden won and I'm a registered Republican.

Who won the debate?

Beverly S. Hill, Tallahassee, Florida — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 03:53:40 GMT

The deed is done. Let's get on with the campaign and get these last 30 days overwith. Barack is clearly in the lead and will stay that way. McCain is disentigrating as we speak and Palin has her nose so high in the clouds she may simply burst from nosebleed in the meantime. Barack has won, plain and simple. It's all over but the shoutin'!

Who won the debate?

P Snow Aurora, OR — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:03:34 GMT

Wake up people. If Biden has been so good why didn't he get to be the presidential hopeful after his 35 years!! in congress. He is just like the rest of the blowhards there. We need the Mavericks.

Who won the debate?

Bill Mahiger, St. Louis, MO — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:03:55 GMT

I thought both Joe Biden and Gwen Ifill dropped the ball. Biden didn't rebutt any of Palin's obvious mistakes, and Ifill allowed Palin to take over the show and didn't ask the follow-ups. Biden also didn't press for specifics on the subjects now on everybody's minds: The economy, stupid!

Who won the debate?

adam, jackson, MI — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:05:04 GMT

I take my hat off for Joe Biden. He knows his stuff

Who won the debate?

Karen, Charleston, SC — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:05:18 GMT

How did this play out for the average American voter?
I found Governor Palin to be condescending, over-prepared and downright obnoxious from start to finish. While I am sure some will go for the wide smile, winks and sarcasm, I just want her and Senator McCain to know that some of us, in fact, many of us Republican and Democrats alike, are looking for answers...real concrete solutions to the situations we are facing. Style over substance won't cut it this time around.
As a Republican and a woman, I deeply offended by the notion that this is the best we have to offer ...at this point, I say this for the whole ticket. McCain's lack of judgment in choosing Palin (clearly for political gain only) shows that he does not care one iota about putting the "country first".
I have been loyal to this party for as long as I can stand. I hung in there with our President despite the direction of the country and our weakening position globally. I am now at a crossroad where I need to decide should I continue to support McCain in his arrogance and apparent lack of integrity OR do I tow the line and cast my vote despite all that's happened since the RNC, the last 2 weeks of gaffes with Mrs. Palin in particular, and now this over-rehearsed dinner theatre performance tonight.
And people wonder why there are so many undecideds...

Who won the debate?

David Ruck Whitehall, Michigan — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:06:25 GMT

Interesting reading some of the reactions here. If you were looking for answers to the moderator's questions, you weren't going to get them from Palin. Yeah... the whole Energy thing? Segway after segway she kept bouncing around about energy and showed little command of the issues besides what can be assume was only what had been uploaded into her head over the passed few days. Biden won the debate on the issues and, I feel, hit a "home run" with Americans when he showed his humanity in choosing to discuss his painful family experiences, while defending the idea that men can also understand what it is like to be a single parent.

Who won the debate?

Robert from Punta Gorda, Florida — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:08:04 GMT

When asked what she thought her achilles heel was, she rambled on about how great her accomplishments are and how wonderful John McCain is. There is no way I could see this woman standing up to Putin.

Who won the debate?

Grace Franklin, louisville, ky — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:08:13 GMT

Why are the message supporting Governor Palin not being posted?

Who won the debate?

Sean Tluchak — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:08:54 GMT

Was Buchanan drunk?

Who won the debate?

Michael Williams, Helena Montana — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:09:24 GMT

This just in...Sarah Palin thinks McCain is a MAVERICK. What I saw was a well rehearsed set of talking points. She flat out dodged certain questions, and doesn't seem to have an achilies heel. It reminds me when Bush was asked if he could identify a mistake he had made. She showed an ability to recite, good for her.

Who won the debate?

Jessica A, Ft. Worth, Texas. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:10:11 GMT

I'd like to point out the actual truth of what she said when she spoke of the Vice President having power over the Senate.
You guys...The Vice President IS the President of the Senate. What she obviously wants is to move that from a symbolic role with only one true action (a vote if there is a tie) and change it into one where the VP actually works with the Senate.
So there is actual constitutional basis for those of you on Hardball who obviously haven't read it.

Who won the debate?

Mary B, Wisconsin — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:10:17 GMT

I agree with Sue B.... Buchanan is off base. I found his comments degrading to women. He also said Sarah Palin was "attractive"...please!! As a woman, I'd like a VP to be known for her brains and abilities...not because she can charm an old geezer like Buchanan.

Who won the debate?

Bob Pasquale — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:10:19 GMT

Since when is totally ignoring a question a debate "tactic"?
When asked about the threshold for pulling the nuclear trigger, you respond with an answer about TAXES??? Yikes.....

Who won the debate?

8isEnuf, Lexington, KY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:10:42 GMT

I found her behavior to be condescending! The fact that she winked repeatedly and threw in several "folksy" tidbits did not impress me, instead, it made me even more fearful that she might be a heartbeat away from the presidency. Not once did she ever answer a question directly and each time she would change the subject. I thought Biden did a good job in that he stayed on message, and, was respectful to her as she rambled on and on!

Who won the debate?

Doug Hendrix — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:10:48 GMT

Don't look back! Translation: Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.

We will have suffered through eight years of a President with a prideful lack of knowledge of history or the lessons learned from it. Suffering through another four years of an administration that refuses to look at how we got here and learn from that reflection is unacceptable and, frankly, scary.

Give her, as Vice President, more Constitutional powers? God help us!

Who won the debate?

Robert J Chester, Galloway, New Jersey — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:11:32 GMT

Wow! Joe Biden was roadkill. It showed that even he, from Scranton and Wilmington, does not believe the dangerous things and lies that Obama says. Go Sarah!

Who won the debate?

8isEnuf — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:11:50 GMT

To Grace in Louisville........maybe there are no messages being posted of support for Palin because there are no such messages being posted!

Who won the debate?

David Peter, Las Vegas, Nevada — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:12:03 GMT

As a working class voter, a veteran of 22 years in the USAF, and a union member, I can think of nothing more scary than Palin becoming the Vice President. It was apparent to me that Palin was more like the old TV add "I'm not a Vice President, but I play one on TV." She obviously could only repeat coached statements, and could not answer questions. She is incapble of stating actual policy. I am tired of her trying to compare being the mayor of a town with 5,000 people to being the Vice President of the United States. She does not have what it takes to be Vice President and McCain showed very poor judgment in selecting her as his running mate. While I have serious disagreements with Biden and Obama on the war - I believe in a more immediate end to the illegal occupation of Iraq - I will have to vote for them next month as McCain/Palin scare the hell out of me.

Who won the debate?

Diane, FL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:12:03 GMT

I have very serious doubts as to the professional aspects that is required by a VP and Ms. Palin. That "Folksy" attitude makes me cringe. It reminds me of a person who is not intellectal and so they cover it up with the "Folksy" attitude. I'm wondering how she would do sitting across from Foreign Digintaries using that "Folksy" language. I find that appalling and totally unprofessional.

Who won the debate?

k temple — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:12:46 GMT

I was surprised at how good Palin was but then I realized she was giving a stump speech over and over. And I agree with Maddow--I thought if she winks and gets any more folksy I may throw up. Didn't we elect a guy last time who was "great to have a beer with". That did not work out well. We need a President and a VP who can think on their feet and answer actual questions asked.

Who won the debate?

chuck sheppard Springfield, MO — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:22:06 GMT

Yep definitely voting for Barr now only hope of changing our situation.

Who won the debate?

John Vandenacre — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:22:40 GMT

Why don't you liberals talk about somthing like Biden LIED at Least Ten times regarding his and MaCains voting records. If Palin lied even Once, the Pathetic Liberals would eat Her for lunch but somehow when your liberal, socialist and have no plan, nothing to pick your opponent apart accept her wink, you can Lie freely about your record and it's OK. Shame on you all. Maybe you watched a different debate than I did. Sarah Palin was Great!

Who won the debate?

E.Michael — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:22:54 GMT

One more wink and I would have gone through the tv. nice lady over her depth needs to go back to being hockey mom, Joe Biden was a gentleman and won the debate.

Who won the debate?

Cindy Wright, Brooklyn New York — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:22:57 GMT

Absolutely, Positively, Joe Biden won the debate, however Sarah Palin made a good show of it for the Republicans...notice I said a "good show of it"...that's all it was A GOOD SHOW OF IT...nothing else!!! WAKE UP PEOPLE.......DON'T GET SUCKERED IN BY THE HYPE!

Who won the debate?

A. Austin, Fremont, CA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:23:23 GMT

i believe that sarah palin had done a good job in memorizing all of her answer to the topics she would want to discuss with! i applaud you for that! i did that too when i was in college...cramming a day or two before the exams!!!

that only shows how bogus she is and i do believe that she didn't do anything good to their ticket. my husband and i love BIDEN a lot! i even cried when he mentioned about his first wife and daughter who both died of a car accident. if you want change, vote for OBAMA-BIDEN. Their the ones who would end this war, the war that brought AMERICA into depression.

Who won the debate?

Jan Lightner, Federal Way, WA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:23:53 GMT

Watched the "debate" with my husband who is a McCain supporter. We agreed to offer no comments while it was on. After about 25 minutes, he muttered, "I can't take it any more," and left. I stayed through it all and all I could think of was, she really IS a post turtle. You drive down a country road and see a turtle on a post; you know it didn't get there by itself; it doesn't belong up there; it doesn't know what to do now that it's there; and you wonder about the guy who put it there.

Who won the debate?

Rebecca Russell — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:23:55 GMT

As a Republican I really worked hard to like Gov. Palin but this debate has convinced me to vote for Obama-Biden. Palin blew the her pseudo-genuine image on national TV by not even acknowedging Biden when he choked up while speaking of the traumatic death of a family member. Little cracks like this will continue to develop.

Who won the debate?

John Bakos, Sacramento, California — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:24:20 GMT

Palin did well, in that she did not flub up badly... a small claim to fame. Biden appeared thoughtful, knowledgable and ... dare I say it ... presidential... Not having been much of a Biden fan in the past, I was impressed. Anyone who watched that and felt that Palin did much more than recite the same campaign slogans, endlessly, is intellectually dishonest. Now, is she educable, almost certainly yes. But is she ready to assume the Presidency in the middle of January, 2009 in a worst case scenario.. almost certainly not.

Who won the debate?

Jerri Brooker, Spokane, WA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:24:24 GMT

Joe Biden had his act together and answered the debate questions professionally; Sarah Palin had a script and refused to answer the questions posed; she talked jibberish at times. She doesn't show the professionalism I expect in a Vice President; Biden does.

I shudder to think what would happen to this country if McCain/Palin are elected and started shooting from the hip. I pray Obama/Biden continue to get the votes needed to be our next elected President/Vice President. This country needs them. They care about working class Americans. They will help get us out of this crisis and back on track.

Who won the debate?

Joni West — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:24:25 GMT

First off, Sarah palin did herself...John McCain and the Republican party very proud tonight. However Chris Matthews was wrong for saying it was 11pm when she brought her baby on stage as part of her ACT (says you)!! Duh, Chris! Sarah was on CENTRAL time so it was only 10pm... actually only 9:30pm when she finished her speech. You need to get your facts right before you sprout out a biased opinion that you think the public doesn't notice.

Who won the debate?

Mattm, Houston, TX — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:24:47 GMT

Both did a good job tonight. Palin and Obama are so equal on experience level (lack there of), just in different arenas. Except Obama's at the top of his ticket...scary!

Who won the debate?

Greg, Portland, Oregon — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:25:52 GMT

I love how low the bar is for Palin. When she started giving shout outs to 3rd graders, I realized: wow, this is the best the Republican party can do??! Too bad 3rd graders don't get a vote.

Who won the debate?

H Hulick Dallas Texas — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:26:28 GMT

To: David Peter, Las Vegas, Nevada
If you are scared of Palin being VP then you must be really afraid of a man with no experience and ties to criminals being President. Change is a word that he uses in his message to the American people and for a man who said he is not the typical candidate Obama has become just that-he will say and do anything to be president. I used to support him till I started asking hard questions about his past and his ties and then I realized that no one really knows anything about him, nor will he let them know anything other than what he allows. He is not the best choice-he is the wrong choice. And Biden tonight-he was caught as he knows he did not support Obama until he was selected to be VP. Palin did the job of relating to the everyday person which Biden did not. I won't vote for Obama which I thought impossible for me to admit to. McCain might not be the best choice but he is the better choice.

Who won the debate?

PJ, PA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:26:50 GMT

Senator Biden answered the questions he was asked which I thought was the purpose of this debate. Governor Palin, on the other hand was evasive and rude. Her presence was not refreshing, it was embarrasing and insulting to those of us who are taking this election seriously. I am curious to know what the critics would have had to say if Senator Biden conducted himself in the same manner as Sara Plain did? By the way, did anyone count the amount of times she used the word also?

Who won the debate?

Cynthia Harmon, Paradise, CA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:27:11 GMT

Sarah Palin is an accomplished actress, beauty queen wannabe, and political competitor. She has been training for decades for her moment on the national stage. As a performer and an actress, I have to admire her talent, but continue to be terrified at the prospect of her ascending to national office. We need to send her back to Alaska!

Who won the debate?

Scott G. Plantation, Florida — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:28:23 GMT

I agree whole heartedly with Keith Olbermann. Palin avoided the questions and defended incorrect facts. But who could expect anything, else given the recent, albeit few, interviews. The blatant and feeble effort she made to attempt to appeal to “small-town voters” was sickening and is not becoming of any person in a position of power. In the end, I doubt any sensible voter, who watched the debate, could deny Joe Biden victory. Palin may not have been destroyed, but neither did she succeed by any measure.

Who won the debate?

L. Brown Ashland,KY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:28:25 GMT

I have seen every debate and watched endless hours of campaign coverage. I lost a lot of respect for Sen. Biden tonight. I heard him deny, over and over again, statements which he made in the Democratic debates. Sarah Palin was more than his equal tonight. He should be thankful she didn't remind America that he thinks FDR was Pres. when the stock market crashed.

Who won the debate?

Cindy Wright, Brooklyn New York — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:29:04 GMT

Who won the debate?

Jean Leeper, Mt. Pleasant, IA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:29:17 GMT

I keep getting lost in Mrs. Palin's answers to the questions. She usually did not answer the question asked and then rambled all over the place.
She answers question more like she is running for Miss America not for Vice President. I am a women and can not take her seriously.

Who won the debate?

Maria Peterson — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:29:22 GMT

It is frightening just to think for a minute that...if Palin is the VP and McCain dies...the country will be on her hands...Yes she is charming, charismatic, and she loves to wink to the camera.What about answering the questions?

Who won the debate?

Dom Furfari, Johnstown, PA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:29:30 GMT

Sarah Palin was sensational tonight. She was representive of America. She connected with the American people. If she can do that well after 5 weeks on the national political scene, I can only image how far she can take this country in the next 4 years with McCain. I just wish the bias MSNBC and CNN networks didn't slant their views toward the democrats to satisfy their own agenda. Just read the comments of Chris Matthews, Keith Olbermann and Rachel Maddow....really, did they actually watch the debate?????

Who won the debate?

Tim, Tucson, AZ — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:29:42 GMT

No bias there in MSNBC's question: Can Gov. Palin reverse the "downward slide" of the Republicans? Palin not only met expectations but exceeded them. Once Chris Matthews and Keith Olbermann finish spooning with Obama, maybe we can get to some serious journalism.

Who won the debate?

Steve Rogers, Loveland, CO — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:29:54 GMT

Politics aside (yeah, right)but did anyone besides my wife and I notice that Senator Biden referred to people from Bosnia as "Bosniaks?" It cracked us up. It was the high point of the entire campaign.

Who won the debate?

concerned in alabama — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:31:03 GMT

I feel Biden brought much more fact to the table. I believe Palin was heavily coached, case in point, when Biden talked in great length about the housing downfall & the bailout bill & it went back to her, she couldn't talk about that. She quickly turned the subject to energy, one of her supposed fortes. She skirted around the issues that matter to our country at this time, but seemed to hit her stride when foreign policy came up. It appeared she was coached. She is nothing but a pretty face & a puppet for the Republican party. If I was on the fence about who I was going to vote for, she just blew it for the Republican party. She displayed her inexperience in many ways.

Who won the debate?

B Hering, Chippewa Falls, WI — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:31:07 GMT

With Palin (read Palin's HANDLERS) deciding that she did not have to answer the moderator's questions, there are two major problems with this tack:
1. This is a bald-faced admission that Palin probably won't know the answers to many questions, so therefore the plan is to ignore any "inconvenient" questions.
2. This approach reflects a continuation of the Bush administration's arrogance--basically saying "we don't have to answer your questions if we don't want to". A moderator or any journalist in a sense represents ALL of us Americans who do not get the chance to ask questions of these candidates in person. A politician who flat-out refuses to answer reasonable questions is thereby choosing to ignore US! They should only do so at their own political peril!

Who won the debate?

Jessica, Minneapolis MN — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:36:51 GMT

Gwen Ifill really did a poor job as a moderator. It was her job to keep Palin on task, and had she, nuance and thoughtfulness would have won out over blatant appeals to obscure notions of American exceptionalism (since when is a good thing?) and "maverickness."

Biden won hands down as a wonk, but Palin probably appealed to "mainstream America" because the Obama campaign made a decision, apparently, to avoid any attack or response to attack, likely because of gender. This, combined w/ Ifill's failure to duly moderate, allowed Palin to get away with a pretty nasty yet fluffy performance that moves me, at least, from the "pity" side of the meter to the "yuck."

Ifill should have anticipated and responded more strongly to her evasion, although perhaps her hands were tied by the recent "controversy" over her book. Too bad.

Who won the debate?

SickenedInOhio — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:38:12 GMT

to H. Hulick in Texas: Obama has ties to criminals - George Bush is a criminal!!! And I bet you voted for him. He gave this country and it's wealth to his family and friends around the world and Mccain promises more of the same. He and his cupie doll - wink, wink, "darn right" and "high five to all the third graders!"

Who won the debate?

RSC Blue Springs Mo. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:38:30 GMT

On several different questions it seemed as though Sarah Palin started to answer the question she was asked and as she answered it seemed something triggered an almost robotic finish to the answer that she had been taught by campaign surragates. Not to mention the fact that many of the questions were totally ignored by her and she then asked and answered her own question that were better suited to her. Biden won.

Who won the debate?

Martha, Roxbury CT — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:38:36 GMT

I really expected Palin to paint Biden as a DC slicky tonight, and am surprised that it was Biden who came across as the "real Joe". The part where he teared up was a beautiful moment for him. But Palin completely shanked it with her non-response. What a self-absorbed witch, she was too busy on her unblinking mission to acknowledge the truth and pain in Biden's answer.

LOVED that she ignored the Achille's Heel question -- she's probably still trying to figure out if Achilles Heel is the PM of Spain, Greece or Turkey. Moron!

Biden hit it out of the ballpark tonight.
Gobama!

Who won the debate?

Susan T, Alabama — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:39:11 GMT

It is hard to imagine the reason McCain picked Palin as a running mate. She seems very proud of her record in Alaska - but is currently under investigation about abusing her power there - and now she wants to be VP -- and EXPAND the power of that office? Does she really think the American people are crazy?
Gov Palin has obviously been "tutored" on debate - and has been given canned answers, which she was unable to give in a clear manner. The two things she DID make clear were (1) she wasn't going to answer anything she didn't want to answer, and (2) she wants to become VP and expand the power of that office.
She comes across to me as someone who will do "whatever it take" ( as she said several times) to get what she wants. I truly believe she is a dangerous person.

Who won the debate?

Josie Tucson Az — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:39:56 GMT

I thought Palin was great she did what nobody expected and i think she caught Biden off guard. Palin went out throwing punches and Biden was trying to block himself but clearly Palin stood her ground and showed that she can run with the best of them. i think MSNBC needs to give Palin recognition and congratulate her instead of the endless slamming of her. Show some credit where its due, if u know Biden lost than just admit it. oh and Biden well i just didnt think he won and i was also very bored when he was talking, i only wanted to hear Palin. i think hearing palin talk tonite i will now decide to vote for mccain/palin

Who won the debate?

Joseph, Louisville,Ky — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:40:41 GMT

I feel that Senator Biden won the debate. I think Gov. Palin sounded too scripted and rehearsed. Many people may feel she won only because she didn't make any mistakes. I can understand that, but its not hard to clear the bar when its been set that low.

Who won the debate?

kerry jackson san diego, california — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:40:55 GMT

I have been watching MSNBC after the debate. I keep hearing what a good job she (gov. palin) did. I beg to deffer. She did not answer one question. Instead she resorted to her script that she was schooled, not unlike the current "no child left behind" doctine which our children and grandchildran are subjected to from this administration. Taught to memorize, not to think!

Who won the debate?

Ron, New Haven CT — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:40:59 GMT

Palin was clearly reading off the script. She was coached to talk about energy(since her state has a lot of oil) if she was not sure about an issue and she did it all night.McCain, the self proclaimed maverick, is a 30yr Washington insider who voted 90% with Bush and is responsible for helping get us into this mess of an economy and foreign policy. We cannot stand four more years of bashing the middle class, enough.

Who won the debate?

pb, wa — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:41:30 GMT

Palin in just to cute for me...the winking...the down home talk...etc. I think I want someone with a little more dignity for my veepee. Also, if I hear again about her extensive experieance I will gag.

Who won the debate?

m. collyer — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:41:35 GMT

Joe Biden was amazing--not too condescending, but wrong, wrong, wrong. Sarah won hands down. She's only been on the national scene for 5 weeks and did an amazing job. She's intelligent and shows great character. She's not afraid to talk straight and tell you what she thinks. Biden is same ole same ole.

Who won the debate?

Buckeye Voter — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:41:46 GMT

The Palin Wink will be like the Gore Sigh.

Silly and unprofessional.

Who won the debate?

Don G, Seattle, Wa — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:42:33 GMT

Very interesting range of answers here!
Biden proved himself to me tonight, he made me proud to be an Obama / Biden supporter! I, too, am entirely sick and tired of Palin thinking ALL of America wants to be treated and/or referred to as Joe Sixpack or a Hockey Mom. Her world view is so, so, very limited. And when the bar that she needs to clear is "Don't Mess Up Too Badly" well, you're not in the same league as the real players. Her responses were canned and practiced bullet points. "McCain and I will fight for you" what is this, a community college debate for commuter representative? She's all shape, no substance. All rhetoric, no material. In a few weeks, when Obama and Biden win the election, Sassy Sarah will go back to her job as governor of the least populated state in the country.

And here's a final word: Mavericks are fine in the movies, but they don't make good leaders. I don't want a maverick speaking for me to the rest of the world, I want an intelligent, learned, capable statesman.

Who won the debate?

Robert Barr — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:42:38 GMT

I think we all; the media, analysts, campaign handlers and yes, we the audience set the bar so low for Palin, that she did in fact appear to have outperformed our expectations. But is that where we are as a nation? Is that what a candidate for Vice President of the United States is measured on - simply to show up and recite from a over prepared and over coached script? Come on, people, what ever happend to the concept of the "brightest and the best" of us ascending to public office. There is too much as risk to even consider that Sarah Palin could assume the office of the Presidency, or even that of a political appointee. There is nothing there there.

Who won the debate?

Barry Hagen — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:42:43 GMT

Does it surprise anyone that the MSNBC folks have posted 42 pro Biden comments and 10 pro Palin comments? Hmmmmmm? Believe me kiddies, there are plenty of comments for both to equally divide if there was not an agenda. And the execs can't figure out why there ratings continue to drop?

Who won the debate?

Rob, Gibbon, Nebraska — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:43:00 GMT

Wake up people, if it was a Biden-Palin ticket, there would be no question of who would win. It isn't about the past administration, it's about the future and these two have it down. Unfortunately, the two running for President don't have a clue.

Who won the debate?

G. Shaw, Victoria, British Columbia — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:47:30 GMT

Well, I am not from the United States but I find your elections fascinating and most entertaining - to say the least. I have been a fan of Pat Buchanan in the past but his purblind partisan support for the moral and cerebral inanity called Sarah Palin is something I find as confusing as it is astounding. While, I would support 100% the values Palin claims she supports - the minute she opens her brash and boastful mouth the incongruities abound. You know she is as alse as the silly winks she keeps giving to the camera. She is a nasty and foolish braggart that desperately needs to be sent back to the backwoods of Alaska as soon as possible. She has no respect for anything other than her unqualified belief in herself. She does all true conservatives a monumental diservice and she made Joe Biden, whom I have many issues with, look like a gentleman. May God help America that the day has come when such a grade-A, blue ribbon, genuine 'Made in America' mental and moral vacuum can make it on to the national stage as a serious contender for the office of Vice President of a once proud and powerful nation. I suppose this is what comes from following political correctness right through to its logical conclusion: disaster!

Who won the debate?

Lena Eubanks, Slocomb, AL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:47:43 GMT

Palin clearly won! She's so down to earth and honest that most of you don't recognize honesty when you see or hear it. I guess you have been democrats too long.

Who won the debate?

Independent Voter, Hollywood, FL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:47:57 GMT

Senator Joe Biden won the debate hands down.

Tell me who is General McClellan?

A heartbeat away from the presidency and she think this is the Commanding General in Afghanistan is this man:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_B._McClellan

Who won the debate?

Kate — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:48:28 GMT

I was really excited to hear that McCain/Palin supports equal rights for gays and lesbians. I can't wait for them to sponsor legislation to prohibit discrimination in employment based on sexual orientation.

Wonder what Palin's evangelical "base" thinks about that?

Who won the debate?

TJ, Dallas, TX — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:48:30 GMT

To Steve Rogers: I was actually impressed that Biden knew that Bosniak refers to Bosnian Muslims and that he knew the distinction. He scores some extra-credit points on that one.

Who won the debate?

Sheri Stevens, California — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:49:00 GMT

Sarah was gutsy and stood her ground! Personally I find her very refreshing. Biden is glib and boring.
She may have appeared "Folksy" to people on the east coast, but out on the other Coast, she comes across Real and honest. Frankly it's a nice change from the typical WA elites.

Who won the debate?

Jean Standish, New York, NY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:49:50 GMT

One of the responders wondered, "Why are the message supporting Governor Palin not being posted?" They're there if you look for them. However, there was very little to be said positively about Sarah Palin's performance. It was obvious she had absolutely no grasp of the complexity of the issues and very little knowledge of domestic and foreign policy.

Who won the debate?

J.Kelly Camden,Ohio — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:50:20 GMT

Not to go off topic but have been flippin' channels since the debate and have not heard one apology to Gwen Ifill for doing what i thought was a very fair and admiral job moderating.

Who won the debate?

T James Brooklyn NY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:50:27 GMT

Sarah Palin displayed better debating style than Joe Biden. However, she confirmed to the American public that she has no knowledge of the relevant issues which makes her a poor choice for VP. Joe Biden showed he is knowledgable on domestic and foregin issues which makes him the better candidate for VP

Who won the debate?

Kathy Moore — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:50:43 GMT

I like Palin! She appeared to be honest and simple-not complicated Washington or East Coast. I felt that I could relate to her. Washington and Wallstreet has some dishonest problems. She spoke to me and I want to work to get American the way it should be; the way our forefathers wanted to see it. Let us not change the vision of our constitution.

Who won the debate?

Linda R. Mobile, AL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:50:56 GMT

Gov. Palin did a fine job. She doesn't speak in circles, she states her points and is clear on her positions. Sen. Biden rambles and his answers are more typical of a seasoned politician filled with double talk. It's sad about his family and I didn't think that Gov. Palin was rude or disrepectful towards him at any time during the debate.

Who won the debate?

Dee, Columbus OH — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:51:17 GMT

Palin reminds me of a student trying to BS a homework assignment. Grade D-

Who won the debate?

Willie Courthers — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:55:38 GMT

I voted for Bush twice. I am a single male who lost his wife from cancer in 2003. I have a daughter who was a teenager at the time of her mother's death. I almost teared up hearing Biden talk about his family tragedy. It was so cold and selfish for Palin to go right on with her recital without showing any kind of human compassion for this man who lost so much. She showed her lack of sensitivity to us "Joe Six Packs." Her reaction was so not Christian. After she did this, it made her winking at the camera look so phony. She didn't win the debate. I will not vote for McCain. Everybody here know that I am right!

Who won the debate?

VA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:56:11 GMT

If the McCain camp is really behind their VP candidate, let her go on the news shows (like Meet The Press) like all other political candidates do. What are they afraid of? That we will see the truth, and see that the folksy governor is not intelligent enough for the ticket? Biden won this debate hands down! But did we expect anything different?

Who won the debate?

david burrows nj — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 04:58:31 GMT

Liberal weenies, wake up, she put it all in prospective, dems= higher taxes, bigger government, defeatist attitude. Rep+ lower taxes, less government and a will to win.

Who won the debate?

Cheryl L, Sedalia MO — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 05:07:07 GMT

Both candidates were well spoken, just in different ways. Biden did some lying. Palin came across to me as believing strongly in what she was saying. Handled herself well. People should look at Obama's past (if they can find the truth of it like a school registration record that shows his religion as Muslim) and ask if one with ties to people who hate us should be president. A big resounding NO NO NO from me. McCain has always been loyal and giving of himself to the people of this country. He has my vote.

Who won the debate?

Susan Thomas — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 05:07:14 GMT

Sarah Palin is embarassing to Republicans. The fact is you like her, but then you realize she did not answer the questions. She was evasive and was totally insensitive to Senator Biden when he became emotional over death of his wife and child. Then I realized this is a tough woman that can shoot a moose and never blink. Fact is she is not capable of becoming VP or President. She should stick to beauty pageants.

Who won the debate?

Leigh, Arlngton, VA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 05:07:38 GMT

Prediction: John McCain's choice of Sarah Palin for the office of US Vice President will backfire on him. Not only will he not be President of the United States, but his political career is over. For good. This isn't a popularity contest. These people carve our futures--and we take their qualifications seriously. He traded fluff for substance--at our expense. He's political toast.

Who won the debate?

Jim Bridges, Lakewood, Ca. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 05:08:16 GMT

Well of course the Libs are for Biden and the conservs are for Palin. What all of these post show as most interesting is the several commited Republicans that have changed their minds after tonight and how no Democrats have.

Who won the debate?

Paul, Athens, OH — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 05:08:17 GMT

PS: I wish that the democratic candidates would at least call out the republican ticket for its lack of imagination: Obama for change, then McCain for change; Obama has no experience; then suddenly a running mate with no experience; Obama wants to change Washington; guess what: Nope, it's McCain/Palin who will do that. I'm not buying a three-legged horse again.

Who won the debate?

hacksaw — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 05:09:36 GMT

wow! alot of jealous women on this board tonite.

Who won the debate?

Joe Carruba Coplay, PA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 05:10:03 GMT

Up until now I have wondered how the heck this woman could become mayor of even a small town let alone governor and perhaps (God help us) vice president. How could someone so obviously inept and just plain dumb have gotten so far in politics? Tonight’s debate was the best she has come across publicly since her speech at the republican convention. I believe the reason for this is simple. In both cases she had a well written script in front of her to draw on. The reason she stated early on that she was not going to answer the questions the way they were asked, is because she flat out could not. Even her little cheat sheets couldn’t possibly contain enough info to allow her to do so and without them she is left to think on her feet or draw on her experience. That is why she not only avoided questions and/or gave rhetorical answers but she also recycled the answers she gave without even changing the wording very much at all. Bottom line; the only place this woman could effectively act as president, is in the type of fictional movie scenario Matt Damon alluded to, because then she will have writers to tell her what to do and what to say. That way if she accidentally blows everything to hell, at least the director can just yell “cut.”

Who won the debate?

ToddL, Austin TX — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:21:04 GMT

Best overlooked line in the debate...goes to Biden when he discussed McCain's health care policies being a "bridge to nowhere"! Odd that it was the one time Palin didn't pivot to her Alaska experience.

Who won the debate?

Jackie Nelson, Vincennes, Indiana. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:22:04 GMT

I started off watching the debate thinking that Biden would tear Palin apart on her very obvious lack of experience, and her lack of understanding of the real issues. But I was surprised, and pleased, to find that he acted like a gentleman, though he had ample opportunities to correct her mistakes, such as calling General McKiernan "McClellan" over and over again. Senator Biden exceeded MY expectations in that aspect, and certainly lived up to them in every other aspect. I would be beyond proud to call him my Vice President.
On another note, I, like many others, found Governor Palin's behavior and remarks throughout the debate extremely disturbing. Her refusal to answer the questions that were asked, in my opinion, not only indicates her inability to discuss and even understand the issues that matter, but showed a cold arrogance that I believe is a dangerous quality for a VP candidate, someone who could possibly end up as the leader of this country, to have.

Who won the debate?

MR, Jackson, MS. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:22:11 GMT

I think it is good a woman was chosen to run as a vice presidential candidate but what does gender have to do with ability? If all that matters is having a woman elected whether she is qualified or not America has the right one in Sarah Palin. She will continue evade all issues and wink away the world as she did in the debate.

Who won the debate?

Bruce Seattle — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:22:12 GMT

Oh wow. I just watched this thing called a debate. First and fore most what on earth was Obama thinking in picking this person Joe Biden? Had Biden been called upon to testify in front of his own judicial committee, he would have fried himself on his plagiarism and comments about Obama not being suitable to lead this country. Obama should have put this thing to bed by picking a person in Hillary that had rightfully earned a place at this debate. Really this would be over. Instead Obama left the door open to McCain to select a woman who has actually done something and earned her own way and not through any appointment or because of who she was married to. True personal grit and empowerment. Then she proceeds to take Joe Biden to school on Iraq, energy, health care and taxes. She is a true outsider, I know you have to say she is stupid because she is a republican, this is a standard response since the days of Lincoln, and it seems a bit overused. On the other hand she left so much information and material on the table about Biden’s and Obama’s record that you have to wonder why she didn’t pull the big guns out, so to speak. She could have hurled Barney Frank and Christopher Dodd at Biden along with Obama’s trophy earning trough eating dinner table called Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. She also should have collared Biden on his vote in 1973 in voting against the Alaska pipe line. Could you imagine today what our country would be going through had his position won. Also she should have tagged both Biden and Obama with losing ideas on Iraq. First Obama would have been out of Iraq prior to the surge (March 2007) so we would have surrendered and had we simultaneously followed Biden’s recommendation we would have broken Iraq into three separate territories, Shiite, Sunnis and Kurds. Wow there is an idea we are glad didn’t come to pass. Yikes. Additionally she should have boxed Biden into a corner on the fact that a tax rebate to 95% of the people is a farce since only 65% of the people actually pay taxes, no real discussion on income re-distribution. Biden and Obama are clearly a one trick pony continue to discuss how McCain is a three-peat of Bush, the message is one that they need to deliver because they have nothing new it would appear. Biden is a solid international spokesperson and can serve this country just not as Vice President. Palin clearly won this debate on so many levels.

Who won the debate?

dawna, san diego,ca — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:22:14 GMT

very intersting to read the posts and the tones from the different party supporters. There seems to be much nastier overtures from Palin fans to those who write positive statements reagarding Biden and/or Obama. Bottom line Palin herself stated she wasn't going to answer the Moderator's questions (wow,wish I would've had those options)but when the bar is set low it's easy to jump over. Biden was good and did his job but honestly I don't think Gwen Ifell was a very good moderator.She didn't keep the answers to questions asked or do many follow up questions.

Who won the debate?

C.G. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:22:18 GMT

I'm happy to hear that I'm not the only one who felt that Pain was condescending and irritating ! EVERY question asked of her was turned into an Energy question ! At one point we just started counting the seconds to see how long it took . If McCain's entire forum is about "experience" how can they justify choosing this highly unqualified and inexperienced person as his running mate ?

Who won the debate?

Chuck Sharp — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:23:06 GMT

Jan, From Federal Way, Your comments abouta turtle on a post was wonderful, funny and right on the mark. I would like to nominate you for VP! I was offended by the attack prior to the debate on Gwen Ifill, she deserves more than to have here reputation soiled by Michelle Makin

Who won the debate?

Fred Kohn, Queens, New York — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:25:10 GMT

This candidate, Sarah Palin, might be a hearbeat from the Presidency? Well, I''m a heartbeat away from running to another Country. It's a caray pospect. The bar was set so low, yet even Gov Palin still couldn't stoop below it. She reflects Sen John McCain's scripted, Fauled policy -- which means four more years of a disatrous path the our Country has embarked upon. She set the frules, she msde it easy for herself. biden could have wiped the floor with some of her non-answers. But he was a gentleman and showed great restraibt. I couldn't have. Besides, if your going to debate with your oponent, you might try to lean his name. It is Not O'Bidebn...it is Biden, dummy.

Who won the debate?

Carol Harris, Buffalo NY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:25:13 GMT

Sarah Palin is a real person. She says what she means and lives by the personal moral code in which she truly believes, complete with all the nastiness of unplanned pregnancies and children who are less than perfect. All of you out there who have perfect lives, who have never made mistakes, never lied, never played political games, you vote for Obama. But don't prick his balloon; it's likely to release all the hot air that keeps him afloat and you'll find that you end up with nothing.

I'll go for McCain. Even with all his warts and imperfections, he's head and shoulders over the competition. He's a honest man, who has led an honest, if sullied life. He doesn't apologize for it, nor does he hide it. We know a lot about McCain. What do we truly know about Obama?

Who won the debate?

Miram T Basic — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:25:13 GMT

Palin is far to be great, BUT she is still a better choice (with McCain) than Obama-Biden. Period.
Biden is a member of "old-boy-club" and God knows that Obama will say and do anything to become a president. He has a number of friends that are clearly racists and dangerous. Why suddenly Obama does not agree with them any more? Or does he, but does not want to show it?
Both Obama and Biden change their opinion, friends and positions as political climate requires. Look our economy and country!
We, Americans had enough of those "know-it-all-boys".

Who won the debate?

J Alan, Minneapolis, MN — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:25:42 GMT

Palin fell back on the energy crisis as a safety net for most of the questions. All Biden had to say was that he was interested in alternative energy as a way to create more jobs and possibly use it as an export. I'm interested in a candidate that will spend a little more money on find new alternitive energy..such as more use of wind and solar, and then sell that to other countries. So even though that was the only point Palin could fall back on, I think her point was flat and unresourceful.(probably like my point right now, but it's late and I'm not running for VP)

Who won the debate?

AmyLynde, Knoxville, TN — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:25:57 GMT

Go Biden! He demonstrated what is needed: knowledge, experience, and civility. He and Obama share a desire to reestablish America as the greatest country, and unlike McCain, are not entrenched in a mindset that would repeat the mistakes of the past 8 years. How could anyone be undecided at this point? Has the VP position been reclassified as an internship? Think of the debate as a job interview-would you hire someone who dodged your questions and when called on it, became hostile and refused to answer? Palin's folksiness, smiles and winks mask a megalomaniac--especially scary given her narrow and oppressive views. She's tagging along with McCain now, but one way or the other, 2012 is her goal. Way scary, folks! (wink-wink)

Who won the debate?

Femi Ademulegun. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:27:24 GMT

I think it was really a good night for both candidates.They both answered the questions according to the degree of their knowledge.All i wil say is for voters to look beyond "beauty"like one of your analysts said.At this age and time,i don't think beauty amount to nothing when the economy itself is becoming ugly.The chinnese are not beautiful, yet, their economy is superb.Gov Palin tried, but she is not just there at all.If avoiding questions is now a tactics, i wonder what educational system would be under their government.Americans should wake up,the country is not loved and adored only by military strenght alone, but by the brains of their leaders.I pray Palin and her boss don't get to be voted in come Nov 4th.A word is enough for the wise.The whole world is watching.Brain and not Beauty transform a nation.

Who won the debate?

ids, Illinois — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:27:57 GMT

If doing well, means ignoring the questions and reading/reciting her talking points when ever she wanted to - she did really great!
It must be the first debate where I have heard a candidate tell the moderator she would not answer the question but speak directly to the people.
Why bother to show up for a 'debate' if you are not willing to answer the questions? We don't need to give her free TV time for a debate and have her ignore the questions.
No one doubted her self confidence which was back on display tonight. It is her utter lack of substance and ignorance of the facts and the world around her that is most frightening. She could not name one newspaper she reads for crying out loud.
It would be a travesty if she got to be the first feamle VP of this great nation & God forbid the first President.

Who won the debate?

Mark Wright — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:27:58 GMT

Joe was gracioius--He could have confronted her evasive dodging of the questions due to lack of knowledge and obvious sexist flirting with the men with "six packs" Please Sarah,get over yourself. Get your history right and move on to other issues than energy. That's important, but not exclusively so. Go Obama/Biden 2008 Mark W. N.H.

Who won the debate?

diana, oh — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:27:59 GMT

gotta answer a post that was made awhile back: maybe the positive palin posts aren't on here because there aren't any...if you feel that strongly about her performance, respond. ps: the media is all a conspiracy and trust me, there's enough conservative media out there to balance everything out ;)

i think palin was impressive, but then again, i was half anticipating her to cry, walk off stage, and complain about the mean media bullying her or some such thing. just imagine if there was a nasty diplomat out there...

and please dont slap me as a democrat. i might just be a republican if the ticket was right - and if john mccain was fiscally conservative like those who voted no to the bill...i think both candidates did well, but if anyone had to visit a foreign leader on the US's behalf, i'd have to pick biden...

Who won the debate?

Tom Schukay — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:28:06 GMT

Oh NOOO, there's no bias here! LOL! I'm surprised you even allowed the miniscule few pro Palin comments- why even bother? You would have everyone believe that this is simply a reflection of the 'overwhelming negative response that Pailn garnered', do seriously believe that your readers come only here, to this one source, for their news? (Gosh, could that be true!?) A simple Google search shows quite the opposite- overwhelming positive response to her showing at the debate. Shame on MSNBC for suppressing truth and fictionalizing a false reality. Y'all would be the ones banning books and censuring free speech, given power. Shades of Pravda...Scary!

Who won the debate?

Kurt, FL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:28:19 GMT

Come on msnbc gang, "give the devil her due"....
I have the most respect for Roger Simon, who "cowboyed up", after being the most hostile, pre-debate, doomsday machine. Haven't heard the word "dumb bunny" used in years.....thanks Rog!!!

Who won the debate?

charle carrolla Nevada — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:28:21 GMT

I think Sarah Palin held her own against all the media being pro obama. I am more concerned with the american public being so blind sided and manipulated with a few simple lines, "mcain is more of bush" bush being the key word, and lower taxes for "middle class", obama's middle class is not the same as you think, healthcare for all????? trillions is spending, how do you think this is being paid for????? Look up the web site for "accorn" and you can see where obama's heart is, its not with "middle class' america. Are all the people on the "obama train" ready to live in a socialist society? I am not and hope my children don't as well. Your associations with different people and organizations do depict what type of person you are and people should really take a good look otherwise come november if obama wins I will have a number, a percentage of how many stupid people are in the country.

Who won the debate?

Mike, Orlando, FL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:28:33 GMT

I am an independent, which seems to make me the commodity these days... My take on the debate...

Sarah Palin's expressed refusal to answer questions not to her liking, and canned sound bites about matters off topic reminded me of this current administrations thumbing of their nose to the American people, Her expressed desire to grab more power for the VP, in the wake of Cheney's role these past years, is unconstitutional and alarming. It doesn't give me a strong sense of change coming from the McCain/Palin ticket.

To put her a 72 year old's heart beat away from the leadership of the free world is unthinkable. Her small town charm is pleasant.. not presidential. Her demonstrated grasp (or lack there of) of a world view is on par with the average high schooler's graduation standards. Her inability to convey an intelligent response or solution for the serious issues gripping our country is unacceptable.

Sure she didn't fall on her face.. she was never pressed into a corner. To call that a success is setting the bar too low for an election of this importance. Why does she get handled with kids gloves? I feel that to do so, sets women back, and diminishes the accomplishments so many have achieved.

Obama might not have been my first choice.. but in light of these past weeks, he is my only choice.

Who won the debate?

Christina Le, Garden Grove, CA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:28:51 GMT

To all who criticized Palin for not responding to Biden's emotional moment when he mentioned his sons: Maybe she did not know what to say. Maybe she did not want to draw attention to the moment that may make Biden chokes up even more and possibly tears up on stage. You heard how his voice broke. I think her not reacting to the moment was actually kinder.

Who won the debate?

T.Hansen, Los angeles, CA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:30:56 GMT

If you check these responses against those on ABC, NBC, CBS and Fox you'll see that a very large number of them are EXACT COPIES across all of the sites. Obviously there are a group of people in the tank for a given candidate (or on the payroll) who are flooding the sites with these responses. Please get a little more creative with this sham, I mean, the exact same wording? Even a couple of identical mis-spellings. Stick to voter fraud, you're better at that.

Who won the debate?

Jim Collins, Columbus, Mississippi — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:31:11 GMT

I agree with the comment "don't get suckered in by the Hpype"... please... don't follow the 'change' message of O'bama and Biden. Now that is hype!!! Palin was poised and prepared tonight. I liked her style and I liked her directness.

Who won the debate?

common sense — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:31:14 GMT

Coming from his own mouth, joe biden told the american people that obama is not ready to be president of the united states and he will be honor to run on the same ticket with senator mccain. shame on him. it's funny how he will say or tell lies just to get elected. This typical lefty. you dont tell peoplel one thing and go do the other, you stick to your words. case rest!

Who won the debate?

Dee Murdock, La Crosse WI — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 13:58:58 GMT

I was disappointed by the panel last night. You all missed the point. Biden won w/ his touching moment recalling the personal story about his wife and children. Look at the CNN tracking. The reaction was through the roof.

Who won the debate?

Kelly, MS — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 13:59:06 GMT

I personally think Sarah Palin did a good job last night. One must remember she doesn't come from Washington and isn't quite as "smooth" as the boys and I personally think that's what our country needs...not someone who can talk a good game but can prove their game with actions...she has proved herself in the way she governs Alaska. I think we need more working class citizens and not POLITICIANS in government maybe then someone would care about the middle class and realize we are the ones struggling. I am truly frightened of someone who can talk his way through anything as Obama does and the way people believe it. Do you truly think he is for the working class? He's for himself and his party...just another example of a Washington puppet.

Who won the debate?

DRT, New Orleans, LA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:00:09 GMT

There is no way that Palin won this debate. Though she met her low bar of expectations, her avoidance of the questions and lack of true understanding of some of the issues was apparent. Regurgitating crammed facts fed to her by political coaches doesn't cut it for someone who's next in line to the presidency.

Who won the debate?

Chris, New York, NY — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:00:14 GMT

They worried that Biden would call her Sarah instead of Governor, and it was Palin who asked to go on a first name basis. They worried that Biden would be overbearing and condescending, and it was Palin who talked down to both Gwen Ifil and Biden when she refused to answer questions. They worried that Biden might come off as sexist simply becasue we was up agaisnt a woman, and he's the one that came out as the family man. They worried that Palin wouldn't know how to answer her questions - Well, at least they got that one right!

Who won the debate?

Linda, Grand Rapids, MI — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:00:27 GMT

Why are the message supporting Governor Palin not being posted? Maybe because there aren't any?

Who won the debate?

Carmen, Hillsborough, NJ — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:01:03 GMT

Mr.Buchanan, seriously now......young, exciting, attractive....do you want her as vice -president or do you want to date her?

Who won the debate?

Don H. Tampa, FL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:01:27 GMT

Although I agree that Biden was much better in the debate and Palin showed that she is not ready to be in the limelight. The real issue is the President. Who is really behing O'bama... Follow the money and your eyes will be opened. Too bad Ron Paul didn't get the necessary support as both McCain & O'bama are not good for the country.

Who won the debate?

ernst seiler, kyoto Japan — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:01:37 GMT

For a country with incredible resources like the US, is that the best choices they can come up with?

Who won the debate?

Deborah O'Toole — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:01:48 GMT

Is it just me or did anyone else hear Palin utter the word "also" about two hundred times, rushing in between her sentences with almost every answer? One commentator likened her to a wolverine grabbing onto the pant leg of a passerby, inserting Alaska whenever she could and not directly answering the questions put to her by the moderator. One of the last questions of the night was what each candidate considered their "Achilles heel," and Palin proceeded to go on a rant about John McCain as if it came from a speech rather than addressing what was asked of her. She also failed to defend McCain's healthcare plan for middle-class America, probably because he doesn't have one.

Her little folksy act and the "I'm just like you" routine rang a hollow note as well. I just don't buy it.

Who won the debate?

JCN - Odenton, MD — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:01:57 GMT

Since when does the candidate run the debate?
Why did Gwen Ifill allow Gov. Palin to say she would not answer the questions?
They might as well have had a chalk board with questions on it.
I hope the next moderator has a little more guts.

Who won the debate?

Dan Miller, Manchester, NH — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:03:19 GMT

Sarah Palin won hands down. NBC, you know it's true but you'll never admitt it seeing what big Obama cheerleaders you are. Spin, Spin away. The American people saw the debate. I just hope they cut through all the NBC lies and judge for themselves. Biden made numerous false statements. Funny how none of your so called "reporters" noticed.

Who won the debate?

linda jones, chicago illinois — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:03:29 GMT

Palin reminded me of an actress taking the stage; all her lines were memorized perfectly. She ignored or completely changed the direction of most of the questions she was asked. The Republican party obviously hired her to do a televion commercial last night for McCain and she was quite good. However, what about the economy, the war, the national debt? If they are the party that is going to change things don't you think they should let the American people know what those changes are, and how they will implement the changes? Dear God, as an independent voter I am compelled to vote for Obama & Biden. I respect Biden and wanted him to get the nomination. I also think Obama will make him an integral part of his presidency.

Who won the debate?

Scott Brewer, Memphis, TN — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:04:38 GMT

I think the expectations for Sarah Palin were so low, just because she didn't fumble the ball again, some folks think 'she won'. Get real! Joe Biden was the CLEAR...let me say that again...CLEAR winner!

Who won the debate?

Rob, Reston, VA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:04:57 GMT

Much more interesting debate than the first presidential one.

I feel I went into this objectively.

- Biden was masterful, much better than Obama even.

- Palin conveyed some key messages, but then again, she didn't answer many of the questions (and wasn't held to answering them by the ineffective moderator)

- Biden's comments about Dick Cheney really hit home for me; so did his remarks about being a single dad

- Palin has charisma, but she hasn't convinced me she understands the issues, or has the intellect to solve complex problems; were her running mate not 72 years old, I might not be as concerned. But he is 72. And she is patently NOT qualified to run this country.

- Biden was his worst when throwing out facts and figures.

- I really hate hearing partisan spokespeople react to these debates. Independents matter, not those who simply repeat party lines.

Who won the debate?

Shannon O'conner, Princeton, N.J — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:05:05 GMT

Imagine Hillary winking after every comment?
Women are not stupid, we will not simply vote
for a woman beacause she is a woman, not at any
time and especially no at this critical time in our
nations history.If she will not answer the questions now, what will happen when she is in office as VP
or possibly president? It would have been great to
see a woman in office, but let's remind our daughters
that they need to be prepared for the careers and
positions in life that they seek. John McCaine had
much better choices, there are many well-educated,
experienced republican women he could have chosen,
unfortunately he was too much of a maverick and did
not take the time to think this through, what a shame.

Who won the debate?

Will, Columbus, Ohio — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:06:40 GMT

Amazing! How anyone could have watched that debate and not have seen that Palin came out on top is beyond me. On more than one occasion she called him out on his stretching of the truth. Unfortunately, the real data can be skewed in both directions, depending on the presenter.
Good luck to us all come November 4th.

Who won the debate?

Aurora — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:07:29 GMT

I am a registered Republican and unfortunately, I do echo the same sentiments as Karen from Charleston, David from Michigan and so many others regarding Mrs. Palin as a poor choice for VP nominee especially her lack of heart when Biden mentioned his children.
My personal reasons for being Republican are God- (Jesus), conservative values & roles of the family so that our families can be strong & stable; but Palin is more concerned with her own desires of career & power. The greatest thing she can do for our country is to raise her children in the nurture & admonition of the LORD instead of her relatives & daycare raising them for her. What happened to "the hand that rocks the cradle rules the world." May the LORD help me to make the right decision for the famliy & country. As the family goes, so does the country. McCain hss missed it here ,too.
Also when the Greta asked the Pakistani leader what he thought of Palin as a leader - he went around the question and she had to ask him again.

Who won the debate?

Dave, Miami, Florida — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:08:27 GMT

Sarah Palin continues to perpetuate the fraud that the McCain/Palin ticket is trying to put over on the American People. They have no plan for anything except making the Health System worse and yet they continue trying to avoid answering direct questions and are unable to list any positive thing they will do. Where is the MAverick in voting with the Village Idiot 90% of the time? How about a few FACTS? I'm a registered Republican but I will be voting for Obama/Biden "for a change".

Who won the debate?

Dale Prosperie Houma, Louisiana — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:09:22 GMT

Binden or Palin. Really does this debate matter? The question is... Will this country support a man that doesn't salute the flag? Doesn't do a good job as senator (hasn't voted more than half the time? Doesn't have a stance on anything. Life or death, who do you trust Obama or McCain. Its a fundamental choice. The American People need to thing long and hard.

Who won the debate?

Evan Cole, Fair Oaks, CA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:11:11 GMT

As an Indepdent, I was going to vote for John McCain many times; but not this year. I am embarassed for him; To chose a VP who clearly is not up to the responsibilites and the duties of that position. Governor Pallin is frightening because of her narrow minded thinking, her manifestation for control over people, her inability to think deeply about important and very meaningful issues and because she clearly doesn't care to know the issues (I won't answer your questions not because I can but because I am uninformed and can't and I do not chose to know). I do not want to wake up one day and know she is our president.

Who won the debate?

Elizabeth Vaughn — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:11:27 GMT

Govenor Palin is an attractive woman and I think she would make a great weather announcer but she is not learned enough to be VP of the USA. She can however recite her lines in a personable way. She does have a BA in Journalism and it showed last night. Biden is a statesman and he will be an asset to Obama. McCain is a maverick and Palin is not an asset to him.

Who won the debate?

Nirav Patel, JC, NJ — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:11:55 GMT

At first I supported McCain because I think he loves America and the ideals that it embodies. I think his experience as a POW and his many years in the Senate would give him the right perspective on what this country needs to overcome the challenges that it faces today. After seeing the performance of his VP pick yesterday, I am disenchanted by the McCain/Palin ticket. I don't think she has the intelligence to lead a country that is facing so many problems, i.e. economy, war on terrorism, war in Iraq, Nuclear Iran, Nuclear North Korea (more dangerous than Iran, and a puppet of the Chinese), Russian aggression, violence in Africa, a global financial meltdown, and the list goes on. A great president needs to have impeccable character, vision, intelligence, diplomacy, and the persistence to carry out the actions that benefit the nation. Examples of great presidents would be George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Lincoln, and FDR. Here are individuals who put aside arrogance and came together with people of opposing views to do what is right for America.
This country is not built on Maverick-ism, one lines, cliches, half ass knowledge of its surroundings, or my way or the highway attitude. It is built on vision, on knowledge acquired from the past (i.e. we incorporated some Sioux Indian democratic traditions), cooperation, and the faith of the American People.

Who won the debate?

Louise Waterloo, IA — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:12:17 GMT

Cutsey, folksey aren't qualifications for VP of any country. That's something you would use to impress your first boss or high school teachers.
Pick and chose which questions to answer? Looks like she doens't KNOW the answers. That's being defiant towards peers and authority. Kinda what we have right now, hey? mmmmmmmm scarey

Who won the debate?

SANDY, ELGIN SC — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:12:33 GMT

I think Sarah Palin is like a one-way street with no left or right turns. She was program to come say what she said regardless to what the question was.I can't believe how cold she was when Joe biden talked about his family after she talked about hers. I was undecided but now i'm definitely NOT VOTING FOR McCain/Palin.

Who won the debate?

D Shelton — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:17:15 GMT

Help I'm overdosing on sugar. That was my reaction to Sarah Palin. She sidestepped the issues and didn't answer the questions. She recited like she had crammed for a test. I'm sure Biden restrained himself from throttling her. We need intelligence, leadeship and experience and gosh darn it not her.

Who won the debate?

Diana Haines, Greenfield, Ohio — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:17:22 GMT

Excuse me, but I think MSNBC is biased for the democrats. The polls from Fox News showed a whole different scenario. The polls revealed that Palin won the debate 87% to 13%. It is obvious you want the public to believe that Palin is incompetent as a Vice-Presidential candidate.

Who won the debate?

Ellen Alexander, Ellicott City, Maryland — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:17:27 GMT

I was very disappointed that even before the debate it was made clear that Sen. Biden would have to be overly nice to Gov. Palin as not to appear a bully. As a woman, I was insulted for Gov. Palin (and I don't even support her) and women everywhere - that in this day and time, and certainly in light of our current economic and world crisis that women who are at a place and time in history to stand up and show that they too can be effective leaders are denied a chance to be debated as equal candidates. If this had been a debate between two male VP candidates there would have been no cautions to be "nice" and maybe then we would have had a real opportunity to see if Gov. Palin really could talk the talk and walk the walk. Hillary Clinton, Nancy Pelosi, and other women should have spoken up before the debates to demand that Gov. Palin be treated as any other candidate and not given preferential treatment as a woman. Shame on the women for not demanding this. So what we got was a debate that was clearly well scripted and left no room for Gov. Palin to shine or dim. With practice anyone can memorize lines with great vigor and vim and Sen. Biden having to play nice instead of really challenging a candidate that could hold the second highest office of this land.

Who won the debate?

GILBERT, LONGWOOD, FL — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:17:39 GMT

WHY DINT THE MODERATOR REQUEST ANSWERS FROM PALIN?
PALIN SUCCEEDED IN SETTING HER AGENDA, BY IGNORING THE QUESTIONS AND STICKING TO HER INDEX CARDS FOR HELP.. THIS COULD BE AN EXAMPLE OF HOW SHE AND McCAIN WOULD LEAD…...IGNORING THE ISSUES AND SETTING AN USELESS AGENDA….ISISNT THAT WHAT WE’VE SEEN FROM OUR CURRENT PRESIDENT & VP??
OBVIOUSLY, SHE IS NOT READY TO STEP IN, AND McCAIN HAS PROVEN HE LACKS JUDGEMENT, BY SELECTING HER TO BE HIS RUNNING MATE.

Who won the debate?

D.W., Nevada — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:20:46 GMT

How does one talk "straight" to the American people if one chooses not to answer the critical life-threatening questions of current issues which plague this country and in essence, disrespect the moderator and her opponent by doing so?!?!?! Can someone please remind me (and Sarah Palin) of what a "debate" is. The last time I checked a debate was "A discussion in which a topic is offered and a difference of opinion is expressed between two or more parties", not where one chooses to ignore the topic in question and discuss whatever topic one chooses by making general statements and stating rehearsed slogans.

I care nothing about how "stylish" she was in this debate, nor do most of the American people (as the polls clearly show). What we care about is "if this woman is capable of assuming the role of President if God forbid something happens to McCain". And after her "stylish" performance last night, its SCARY as heck to even entertain the thought that she possibly could!!! She is now and would remain at the end of the day being another political puppet. And we already have one of those!!!!

Who won the debate?

ron garrett, Tyler, Texas — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 14:21:00 GMT

What scares me is an Obama presidency. He has absolutely zero experience. The dems keep pointing to the fact that Gov. Palin is only a heartbeat away from the presidency. What about Obama?

Who won the debate?

David Ward, North Las Vegas, NV — Tue, 07 Oct 2008 00:42:10 GMT

McCain going negative, just turned me off. Obama will get my vote

Who won the debate?

Marsha Gardner Lake Havasu City, AZ — Tue, 07 Oct 2008 15:07:43 GMT

Joe Biden tried his hardest not to be condescending. For those of you who think Ms. Palin was "acting", get real! She wasn't reading from a script. I felt she spoke from the heart. Sure, she was prepared, as was her opponent. For those of you who think she's been preparing all these years.....!!! Get real. She had no idea she'd end up being on a ticket for VP. I think the idea of someone that hasn't been so "involved" in Washington a great idea. Do you really think Joe Biden hasn't helped get us where we are today financially with all his years experience. Look at his record. Has the average working class citizen been helped? Who has controlled the Senate these last few years? What do we really know of B.O. and his supporters?
It's all politics. They'll tell you what you want to hear....both sides!

Who won the debate?

Hope De Cleene — Wed, 08 Oct 2008 03:09:37 GMT

Upon the conclusion of the town house debate between Obama and McCain, 10-7-08: I believe the debates are a forum through which each (or any) candidate should present his/her political views and opinions to the public. Why is everyone always speaking about "winner" and "loser" after every debate??? One contestant will win the Presidency. "Winner," "loser," bleaaaagh. . . . November brings the contest.

Who won the debate?

gavin dovey — Wed, 08 Oct 2008 03:29:39 GMT

WALK SOFTLY , AND CARRY A BIG STICK
WHY CHRIS MATTHEWS`LATENIGHT HARDBALL TEAM SHOULD PAY ATTENTION , PLEASE
i really have to draw attention to a moment in tonights debate which was cringe worthy.....

senator obama responding to mcain by saying , my opponent says "im green behind the ears" i like to spout a load of stuff(im paraphrasing)
it even got a chuckle out of mcain to the point he was laughing sarcasticlly thanking obama for his endorsement..
at that moment , in a sencond , obama pivotted and brought to light infront of all those people , mcains comments about bomb, bomb, bomb , iran
people at msnbc please play the video of mcains face on a loop this evening as the words left obamas mouth
chris matthews` team on the midnight edition of hardball please revisit this video
and highlight the
DRAMATIC CHANGE IN MCAINS DEMEANOR
it was uncomfortable to watch.

Who won the debate?

Steve Kay, Annapolis, MD — Wed, 08 Oct 2008 03:55:28 GMT

Re the Tuesday Obama - McCain debate. The use of the reference to Sen. Obama as "that one" brought be back to my army days in the south. The real meaning of that term is simply "that [n-word]" !

I wouldn't let McCain be a dogcatcher.

Who won the debate?

Rosemary Sanchez, Schertz, Texas — Wed, 08 Oct 2008 04:00:57 GMT

This is the only time we meaning me and my family have gotten really involved in the Presidential Debate and of course the MSNBC news. I have been watching McCain and Obama very closely. I am very please of how Mr. Obama will look at you and answer your question directly. McCain will go in circles and Palin will not answer but make her own questions and answers. Another thing that really bothers me is that McCain wife was once a drug addict and forging signatures and no charges were file against her. And she also made over 6 million dollars last year and won't release her tax return. Why! What are they hiding or afraid of. And Palin she is an unfit mother to begin with. If she can't take care of her children CAN SHE TAKE CARE OF THIS COUNTRY when we are falling. And what about not firing her bother-in-law. Apparently they think it serious because they are opening the case. This couple should be in comedy not in the White House. You know I was always told not to judge until we see what we have done yourselves. I guess this does not pertain to McCain and Palin. We need change not another Bush. Look what at what he has done. GOD TO WE NEED CHANGE. Please Americans let's wake up!! Let's give Obama a chance.

Who won the debate?

Barbara Duke lockport il. — Wed, 08 Oct 2008 17:53:00 GMT

Just the idea of that woman being in the white house even as a visitor scares me.