Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Bob Clark Lakeside Arizona — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:38:24 GMT

Chris,

I watched your show. I watched you. I think you were sincere. That was refreshing.

Sincerity, that's what counts in all of this, right? The politics, the talking heads, the polls, the blogs, the shots at the candidates. No PC.

By the way, Ms. Giles is a refreshing and frank voice.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

CJ, New York NY — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:39:01 GMT

Chris - While I doub that your handlers will approve this message, you have disappointed me. As for someone who did not put much stock in your opinion originally, you have now sunk to a new low by caving on your "hardball" stance. Grow a pair and learn to stand by your words. Perish the thought that you offended the Clinton faithful - you are disgraceful.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Arlene Joyce, San Francisco, California — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:41:11 GMT

Chris, I heard your comment about Hilary when you first made it and it was clear to me that you meant no disrespect to her. You are my favorite political pundit and have been for years. I love your enthusiasm and willingness to call it like you see it, uncensored and unvarnished.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

AJ Graham, San Diego CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:42:10 GMT

I am a female and was raised in New York State. and Live there for about 15 years of my adults life the rest of the time in California. Hillary Clinton had never lived a day in that state before becoming senator and I feel that i will never go back to live in a state that sold the senate seat to a person who had never live there. My step father who still lives there does not like her and has lived there his whole live

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dave F — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:42:54 GMT

Chris, you simply do not have control over your emotions. the contrast from your reaction to the new Iowa and New Hampshire results are night and day, because you are too into the moment, without thinking about the overall context that you certainly are capable of describing.

I am also reminded by your overreaction to Bush's "mission accomplished" moment. you could barely contain yourself, while your later reactions to Bush and the war would be much different.

I am truly a big fan. but get a hold of yourself.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Cynthia, Deptford NJ — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:44:01 GMT

The reason I watch Hardball every single day is because I love the way Chris just tells it like it is, without appology. I always liked the way he fast talks everyone and is so smart and witty. It is a fast paced show and Chris is a fast paced guy, and I like him that way. But...to have him appologize to the Clinton camp for saying what everyone is secretly thinking anyway just seemed wrong somehow. It did not seem that it was really Chris' words, but the network's words. Like someone poured cold water on a hot topic. Could it have been Clinton pressure?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Pedro — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:44:18 GMT

People don't like your comment because you are totally biased. As a member of media who supposely should be objective, you and some of your collegues in NBC News do not hide your support for Obama and have made many critical and unfair comments towards Hillary. Don't you get it. After reading your "explanation", it does not change anything. You speak your heart that is why you make those comments. You are no different from those politicians who make rhetorical execuse but never really admit or stand by their words/decisions.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Ed Cooper, Leesburg, Georgia — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:46:25 GMT

Chris, there will always be those quick to leap on a word misspoken. You've long since proven your mettle and evenhandedness. Keep doing what you do, "self-respecting and conscience free." Oh, and if you have the time, check out my web site.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Eddie, Los Angeles CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:50:14 GMT

Mr. Matthews,
You are a pompous windbag who has lost touch with your so-called heart. Was this an apology? It kind of sounded like one, but without the actual words "I apologize". I started calling your show Softball long before you had Ann Coulter on for an entire hour. You are an insider who is caught in the spin cycle. Maybe you should take a Sabbatical an explore the Virtue of Humility. Then come back and write a column taking responsibility for being callous. Please don't believe your hype, you add nothing to the National discourse.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jane Doe, Nashville, TN — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:50:55 GMT

You should be fired or take a vacation. You're a journalist who has demonstrated that you cannot be trusted to deliver a great product. You insulted a female and according to your sexist attitude, a woman shouldn't be a candidate for any office . . . period.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Peggy D, Santa Rosa, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:53:48 GMT

Mr Matthews has been repeatedly disparaging of Mrs Clinton over the last few months - it has been a trend certainly not isolated to one appearance. Chris has seemed so smitten by Obama that he ignores smarmy behavior in that campaign and jumps on every opportunity to sneer at Hillary.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

John, la — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 02:59:58 GMT

Chris matthews neeeds to start talking harsh about obama's lies...like taking money from lobbyists and voting for funds in iraq!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

TruthnMedia — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:01:09 GMT

LMAO Chis caved in to Media Matters, no Balls on hardballs, ,when it comes to the Clintons

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Debbie, Harleysville, PA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:01:27 GMT

Oh Christopher,
I was watching when you made the statemnent on Morning Joe and was surprised by it. After hearing the full explanation I understand. You must realize "we" don't know everything you know -- some of us missed your point in the short version.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

George Kalogridis — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:03:55 GMT

Chris does not get it.

It's a pattern of misogyny that he has displayed over the years, not one incident; the Hillary business was simply the most blatant. And we don't buy his apology; we know he had to make it only because of all the critical e-mails MSNBC has received. I'm a 55 year old white male and I can't take his poor treatment of women. If he was an MSNBC executive you would have fired him years ago.

Chris has to go. There is a reason behind his poor ratings. His attempts to put current events into historical context are nonsensical non-sequiturs. His love of politics and politicians is not a basis for reporting on politics. He is out of touch with the general public, his reporting only feeds his ego. The best comparison of his current work is that of a gossipy fish wife.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

cathy Washington NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:04:25 GMT

Now will you get back to playing hardball with the Clintons?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Loretta Edmonds New York, NY — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:08:35 GMT

January 17, 2008
Dear Mr. Matthews,
I'm pleased that you addresed the issue of your hostility toward Hillary Clinton's campaign this
evening.Although I am a great fan of yours and
watch the show every night I was beginning to
feel that I could no longer tune in because of
the unrelenting attacks against Senator Clinton.

Until recently I was supporting John Edwards
who is a man of ethics, intelligence and a
great communicator.

I have now decided to work for Hillary Clinton
whether the pundits believe she can win or not.

She is expected to adhere to a standard that
is not being applied to the other candidates.

Is she tough ? She had better be for anyone
weaker than she would be destroyed by these
constant attacks.

Can one imagine the reaction had she admitted
to drug use, no matter how far in the past?
There would be a constant drumbeat of scandal
that would never subside.

I know what politics is like for I worked in
several major campaigns and saw it from the
inside.

I am a fellow Philadelphian by birth and share
many of your educational experiences and
religious background. I hope you read this and
learn how at least one of your fans feels.

I will be unable to watch on Friday, Jan. 18th
but will look for you again during the Nevada
caucus coverage. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to express these thoughts.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Mac, Winston-Salem, NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:08:43 GMT

I have been wondering the same thing about Chris ever since New Hampshire. It seems that he has been getting heavily pressured by somebody in the Clinton camp to absolutely brown-nose her. Now we have both Andrea Mitchell and Chris Matthews to listen to about how great Hillary is. Chris' view on the Las Vegas debate was absolutely apalling. Nobody else seemed to think that Hillary did as great as Chris did. We also had to watch the MSNBC cameras on Clinton signing autographs 80% of the time to Obama only 20% and never on Edwards, all while Chris and Andrea were doing their brown-nosing.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Yvette Lewis, Bowie, Md — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:09:03 GMT

Chris,
You do fire people up, me included. Sometimes that's good and other times its questionable. But I think the hit job the Clinton's are doing on you and NBC is wrong. If Hillary is such a strong candidate, nothing should be able to derail her. The fact that they feel you can means they are not as sure of her as they would like for everyone to believe. Hopefully we are in the last throws of the Clinton era, we can turn the page and Chris can be Chris again. Good luck.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Heather Peterson Battle Creek, Michigan — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:11:24 GMT

I have always liked the Clintons until this primary campaign season. I fail to see what Matthews has to apologize for. I watch all the cable news channels and he remains my favorite.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Wayne Grills, Kingsport, Tenn. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:14:48 GMT

Hi, Chris:
Hillary is no Margaret Thatcher. The voters know this. Hillary doesn't. Who is kidding who. The voters know a vote for Hillary is a vote for King William's third term. AAARRRGGGHHHH!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

jim watts, bonner springs, ks — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:26:41 GMT

all of this is no excuse for the personal attack you made on senator clinton. you are trying to manipulate public opinion, not comment on it. this has become very apparent in the last few weeks. i have discontinued watching your show and have put you in the same category as bill o'reilly, who i haven't watched for years.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Tom T Las Vegas Nevada — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:27:47 GMT

Chris you truly have a distorted view of reality.

Bill Clinton has been a womanizer from the day he became governor of Arkansas. Hillary stands by him because as Lyndon Johnson once said when asked why he would accept second place on the 1960 ticket with
John F. Kennedy, with less power than the Senate majority leader: Johnson replied, "Power is where power goes". Hillary does not stand by him for better or for worse, but as a path to power

Standing by a man who was unfaithful to her all these years is a lack of character, not a sign of character.

The comments you made about Hillary are as twisted as the comments you made about George Bush being a president who can stand and deliver a strike when he threw out the first ball at Yankee Stadium.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

RealB.G. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:29:45 GMT

Mr. Matthews,
I am so sorry you had to apologize. Your apology was a set up to allow Sen. Clinton to play the victim card-again. I just watched Sen. Clinton on the Tyra Banks show talking about the Lewinsky affair and why she chose to stay. She even went as far as giving advice to other women about how they should decide what to do in the same situation. I have been blown away by the level of manipulation they are able to use against the media; not to mention the public swiftboating against Sen. Obama. I will close by admitting I was not a fan of your show at the beginning of the campaign season, but I have not only come to respect your show but I enjoy you. In particular, your deliberate efforts to provide diversity not just based on ethnicity, but perspective is remarkable compared to all your colleagues on all the networks. I do have one request: monthly debates between Mychael Eric Dyson and Pat Buchanon. Honestly, their debates are must watch television. I would also recommend Cornel West or Tavis Smiley. Keep fighting the good fight. It is hard to be a prophet in your own land.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Phyllis Yee, San Francisco, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:32:30 GMT

Chris,
I didn't hear what you said about Hillary but I have heard you say many other disrespectful things to & about women in public life including Hillary Clinton. You need to do a better job of treating women more as equals. I don't like the way you cut them off but the men get to speak their minds. It's especially acute with Andrea Mitchell. Your hostile feelings toward Hillary Clinton have been abundantly clear on many occasions. This goes beyond your mantra of truth & honesty. It is insulting, rude & degrading.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

D Robertson, Boulder, CO — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 04:35:58 GMT

I found Chris Matthews' apology to be politically correct excrement.

What was said about Hillary Clinton was certainly no worse than Matthews has said about Mitt Romney during this campaign cycle. Compare it to what Matthews said about Rove, Cheney, Bush, et.al. and it pales in comparison.

So the people who Chris Matthews respects who called him on the carpet are obviously partisan Democrats.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Roberta Powell Cookeville, Tn — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 04:37:52 GMT

Chris, I have watched your show for years. It is so much fun to disagree with you or your guests. I saw your show the night of your Hillary comments and even I was affended by your callous remark. Your explaination sounds sincere and I can accept it. I do not call it an apology because no where in it is the words 'I am sorry'. The promise to do better is good enough for me.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Diane Vaughn — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 04:38:07 GMT

Chris:
Please keep messing up. Because as more males react with sexism, it'll just galvanize the women vote, which would be fabulous. Not sure what debate you'all were watching; but the one I was watching the big moment was Hillary's considered, and well thought out response to Obomb'em's "Yeah, sure, I'll go after them first and think later." As for Edwards, he's like the younger brother bleating, "me too! me too!"

There is ABSOLUTELY no question, that she's the most qualified for the job, and yes, wife experience counts. But she has a LOT of work experience and has handled herself superbly as a senator. Remember: right now the number is 16 and the magic number is 35 women senators. Don't think for a moment we'll give up this fight. There's waaaay to much machismo in the media and the senate and it absolutely needs more women and we need a women president. And, Hil is ideal.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Harrison, Andrews, NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 04:41:39 GMT

Chris, what took you so long to admit your mistake. Up to this period of time, I have enjoyed your show and the up-beat you bring to the game of politics. With your consistent Clinton-bashing show after show, it was most wearisome! I find that my friends and I have great difficulty attempting to watch your show; you've lost a great deal.

At least you've taken ONE STEP at addressing SOME of the unkind and malicious attacks upon Hilliary Clinton - both for being a woman running for public office and being a politician you've decided you do not like!

In my community, you've lost a large and faithful-fan base! GOOD LUCK with the work to regain it!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Genie, Bellevue, OH — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 04:50:15 GMT

Chris Matthews seemed sincere in his appology. The problem is that he has shown a lack of respect to women at many other times. He acts like some guy at a bar trying to chat them up when they appear on his show to do their job as a reporter or commentator. Lack of respect is a step toward or even a sign of misogyny.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jill, Kensington, CT — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 04:57:34 GMT

Chris,

I love you, love Hardball and The chris Matthews show and loved you on Leno last night. The format of your show lends itself to saying things in a rushed and brief way but the pace of the show highlights how smart you are and how passionate you are about politics. And your good heart almost always serves you well.

But do you really believe that about Hillary? I think the Clintons already had a plan for Hillary to run after Bill's time in the White House was up. It is why she stayed with him, don't you think?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Carolyn, California — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 05:29:44 GMT

Thank you for that apology and clarification. Chris I like your show because of your passion for politics and never thought you meant ill in your remarks. I think what's happening, the environment being created by the press, is new territory due to having a viable female and minority candidate. I can't believe I am saying this, but I think primary night in Iowa Joe Scarborough had it right...I'm a woman, and I find the coverage of Hillary so biased it's offensive to me. I realize she's a polarizing figure, but come on...she loses and every article is scathing and personal, always accompanied by the most unflattering photo possible. She gets a little emotional she's either weak or faking it. The coverage of the men would never stoop to that level. I think the PC levels of everyone are at an all time high right now. So thank you again, for your apology, and for your passion. I need it--I can't decide who to vote for! Talk about your firsts!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Tim F., Palm Springs, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 05:33:01 GMT

Chris,
I appreciate your apology and explanation on this matter. I have been a solid fan of you and your show for 10 years. Lately, your hostility and outright nastiness towards Hillary has made me not want to watch your show any longer. Even though the style and tone of the show is "hardball", we still want you to maintain some level of respect and objectivity for all people. Everyone I know have lately been calling you the "Bill O'Reilly" of MSNBC because of your hostility and harshness. I hope they all get to see your apology/explanation and, therefore, remain fans.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Cynthia, Syracuse, New York — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 05:34:01 GMT

Chris,
I heard your explanation of the misinterpreted quote on Morning Joe, and I thought it was historically factual and complete, and I only wish you could have had the Jeopardy Charity Tourney--HA! Yes, it may have sounded callous if one is looking to run with it as it seems Barbara, Gloria and others have. The reason I watch you is that I want to be well informed, not spun-- you are reflective continually as you--yes, enjoy politics... I find your work offers clarity, thought provoking conversations and important ideas for me to ponder as well as excellent "primary sources" for guests... So, though no apology needed, it is accepted from a 40 something liberal feminist who enjoys her honest, intelligent, energetic, important source for politics...thanks for your show and commitment to it!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Eric W, Washington, DC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 05:39:04 GMT

Chris: there's an old biblical phrase that goes something like this: "Out of the abundance of the heart, the mouth speaketh".

I think there is a level of sincerity to your explanation of these unfortunate events, but perhaps the nature of "fastalking" is the very reason why you got (quag)mired in this controversy.

Another biblical phrase: "There is a time to speak, and a time to be silent".

Don't put the Hardball ratings and your own popularity above your guests and those you critique.

I'm not a Clinton fan, but there is a level of decency that should be excercised by media personalities who (unfortunately) can influence millions with a turn of a phrase and a particular kind of spin that can alternate between professional obligation and personal angst. Take this into serious consideration as you play Hardball, and also "love this country."

End the spin by extending a sincere apology to Mrs. Clinton, and make sure that it originates from your heart, instead of your head.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jackie, Newington, CT — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 05:48:08 GMT

Hey, Chris, I started watching you in 2000 because you did ask the tough questions and and you did bring up the tough points and ultimately, at the end of the day, you treated your guests with respect. I am the political junkie I am today because of you. Thanks...I think. You didn't mean to be disingenuous to Hillary. Now put it behind you.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

kay, apo ae — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 05:54:50 GMT

Cynthia from Deptford NJ,
No it was not Clinton pressure. There are a lot of people complaining on the blogosphere about Chris Matthews' attitude toward all women, not just toward Hillary Clinton. I am a Matthews fan, too, but have noticed that his comments to female guests can sometimes be unprofessional. An apology was in order.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dick N, Port Townsend, WA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 05:56:49 GMT

I'm sorry to see Chris "making up" with the Clintons. And this one day after Brian Williams on Nightly News lobbed friendly softball questions to Hillary. I do wonder about motivation here. Is NBC calling the shots, not wanting to be on the outs with the next (they think) President? There was no need for Chris to apologize.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Shirley Burris, West Fork Arkansas — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:01:51 GMT

HardBall is the only political program I watch on MSNBC because of the respect I have for Chris. He is tough but he has to be to get answers and to make people think. We have too many people with the mindset that that they will vote for the candidate who "looks presidential", "is a woman", "is African American", "is a Christian" etc, instead of their solutions to problems and what in their background makes them a leader. I am tired of hearing about 35 Years of experience but no details, of tremendous amounts of money spent on advertising, while others can get their message across with little money, and of questions not being answered by the candidates. I am a 72 year female who has voted for 50 years, crossing party lines several times. This year I have not yet found the almost perfect candidate and I count on people like Chris and Tim to help me.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

kay, apo ae — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:03:07 GMT

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jim Sanders, Tucson, Arizona — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:03:24 GMT

Sorry, Mathews has have been passive-aggressively hostile to a lot of people over the last couple of years.

He constantly interupts people, takes ten sentences to ask a question and frankly, is a bore.

MSNBC only has Obermann and little else. How pathetic the press is in our country. This is the same pathetic press that never challenged Bush until too late and now Mathews thinks he is challenging by silly, surly comments.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Okey,Hamden,CT — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:08:33 GMT

I watch "Hardball" always because it is not biased.Chris I think that you are correct with the way you said and presented it.Please be reminded that the truth is always bitter to the ears and when someone is totally committed to saying the truth always,it becomes a habit for the person and he/she would not have hard times remembering previous comments because once the mouth is opened to speak it will always say nothing but the only and only truth.It is important to note that this is not a conventional or popular position in the ugly world of our today politics where you have chosen to pitch your tenth.The people on the other side trying to say only the things that men will like and want to hear and not what men need to hear and know, in most cases that I have checked with "History" they always run out of luck because the voice of truth is always the "still voice of God" among human race,call it the voice of Justice,Peace,Boldness,Joy & etc that makes it's way to the hearts and souls of humans,when it finds it's way into the hearts of the truthful humans it brings the assurance of hope,but when it lands into the hearts of the untruthful humans it often times stirs up resistance ,outburst of hatred ,resentments,oppositions of all sorts,manipulations,$ etc.

Chris, I want you to be encouraged because your likes in our society will surely go places,attain greater heights ,shine like stars. History has it that Truth will always prevail over untruthful,such truth are the legacies of the great men and women that have served this great Country in different capacities with conscious efforts to give truth a chance,such legacies cannot not be erased from the very foundations that holds the pillars of this Country together from generation to generations to come,such bold truth will not go unnoticed by men and women that love the truth.

I am one of your great fans,a disciple,student and advocate of Truth around the world.Please continue to join the echoes of Mother Nature to ensure that Truth and Peace have their chance to make America what we are and should be in the eyes of the whole world at large.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

John, San Francisco, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:19:24 GMT

Chris, anyone who watches your show even once a week will know that you aren't coming at Hillary from a dark place. We can tell that you get excited about Obama - but we know that your first committment is to calling the plays like you see them regardless of who your analysis criticizes.

I respect your forthright explanation of your comments.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Eric, NY, NY — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:21:09 GMT

Chris,

I did not like your original comment as it struck me as a bit sexist and biased but I also know that many times in your profession and in everyone's life that our mouths move faster than our minds sometimes. What is important is you understand how some may have taken what you said and addressed it. Kudos.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

MM — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:25:55 GMT

Love Chris Matthews - hope Camp Clinton did not get to him. He has nothing to explain - he was 100% right about Hillary the first time he said it.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

girrly, Sanfrancisco CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:30:03 GMT

Chris,no wonder you are the greatest pundit. I don't have Msnbc on my television, because I cann't afford. After visiting the your website and watching you speak, I literally laugh and enjoy watching the show over and over on the internet. Your enthusiam and pation have got me more interested in politics, I mean 08'election.Thanks to you. This year, my one vote will make a difference.I don't watch Jay Leno but I stay up late to watch you on the show.My only exhortation to you, is try to be fair to all the candidates and critisize them when you need to. You praise Obama and disagree with him sometimes. Same applies to Hillary, Edward and the rest. After all, this is what makes politics interesting.Keep up the good work and Happy anniversary! "Ha"

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Darcy Gagnon, Tyngsborough, MA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:34:59 GMT

Chris, it has always been so apparent that you could not stand the Clintons. During President Bill Clinton's years in the White House, you did not hide your emotions ever, and it was obvious you felt the Clintons did not deserve your respect. So what else is new? The so-called disgrace of the Clinton White House was so ridiculously mild compared to the screwing of the Constitution and every honest American that the current administration is undertaking that I can only say - thanks for EVERYTHING!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

jim, ca — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 06:53:59 GMT

Chris, if you want to show some gender neutrality, then let's hear you talk about how John McCain took advantage of Cindy Hensley McCain's family connections to get into AZ politics.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Janet Houser — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 07:03:49 GMT

I doubt the sincerity of your comments since you have relentlessly reviled Hillary Clinton for months. You seem to have a bizarre fascination with her. You need to get over it. Your show is nearly intolerable due to your negative comments about Senator Clinton and other powerful women who clearly intimidate you.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Edward — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 07:06:06 GMT

Chris that apology was necessary because you really crossed the line the last couple of weeks. I like how you have so much passion about the election process however you have to be unbias. We like your honesty on issues but when you try to force feed candidates down our throat this is when you lose us. Your apology is a step forward in the right direction to reconnect with your loyal viewers. Keep up the good work.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Joe Jara vallejo, ca — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 07:10:53 GMT

How many crows have you eaten after all the
criticisms of Hillary and your cheerleading
for Barrack especially after the pollster debacle
in New Hampshire. Your opinions are sickening
and you don't let your guests finish their sentences.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Kathy Richardson — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 07:16:25 GMT

Chris, I appreciate your sincerity, honesty & enthusiasm...always enjoy your show with lots of insight & truth. Please do not go overboard now with your guilt (or please, don't tell me Bill Clinton is pressuring you, too? His statement that the press was unfair to Hillary seemed incongruent with what I saw happening)and give her more breaks than Obama. I was really disappointed in your enthusiastic declaration that Clinton "won" the debate & neutralized Obama & Edwards. I hope as you analize it closer, you will see that it is Obama who always takes the high road (forgiving Clinton & her campaign for the continual unwarrented attacks; MSNBC had an excellent summary of the "racial" events, which were totally Clinton's doing), is honest (his acknowledged "weakness", which obviously has not interfered with his ability to build the best organized campaign from scratch ever seen!), is equally knowlegable & "experienced" as Clinton and is "Presidential"(an inspirational leader, intelligent, high level of integrity). He is more consistant on his positions and doesn't take PAC money like Clinton (why did Brian decide at the last minute not to allow Edwards to ask his question about pharmaceutical lobbyist money to Clinton as well? And then Brian very rudely refused to acknowledge that Obama had a question he was not allowed to ask a candidate...so Clinton had NO questions asked of her!!) And Bill Clinton wants to accuse the media of not treating Hillary fairly? The Clintons represent the politics of the past...the good ole boy (girl)favors, money, negative campaigning, corruption and half truths. Has everyone forgotten that Bill Clinton LIED to the American people? How can people trust him? In Iowa, we had a long time to get to know the candidates and their campaigns up close & personal. We got it right in Iowa...Obama will lead us to the promised land (if we all work hard!)...he is the real deal...let's not let this truly unique leader go. Please give him a fair shake!!!! He's trying to lead us on a new path & is up against great odds as he tries to beat the corporate Clinton machine.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Temple Green, Greensboro, NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 07:17:05 GMT

Your remark about Hillary Cliinton disturbed me a great deal. I am not Hillary's biggest fan, but what you said made me uncomfortable. I'm glad that you now realize your mistake. I have always enjoyed your show and will continue watching.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

jon, battle creek mi — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 07:33:17 GMT

Why did you apoligize for speaking the Truth Chris. Everyone knows the only reason she is where she is is because of the Hummer Bill got. She is the worst frontrunner canidate the Dems have ever had.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Christopher j New orleans la — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 07:56:35 GMT

Christopher It Is About Time That you Showed The Class!!!! That You Demand Of Others

Good Luck On you Your Redemption

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Nic Wildeman, Newcastle, WA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:04:48 GMT

Mr. Matthews: To rely on your 'good heart' without meaning to deflect your accountability under the guise of pure intent... THAT is the mark of good character.

Well done.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dave Latchaw, Martinez CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:14:01 GMT

It might save you a lot of trouble if you were to think about what you're saying before you say it. I don't think it would hurt the pacing of the show too much.

While you're at it, try listening to what your guests are saying before you interrupt them with the next question.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

RAUL ESPINOZA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:16:28 GMT

We love you, your fair your tough but your honest. hey at least your not o'reilly. he's an idiot and a lier. Like do they really think that the american people are that stupid? mispelling letters on there programs so people can read them incorrect, putting democrat under republicans subtitle, they do all kinds of bogus stuff on there. Losers. i hate fox

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Ken Liddy Philadelphia — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:17:36 GMT

Chris, when I heard you on the "Morning Joe" show last week, my jaw dropped. I replayed your comments a few times to make sure I heard you correctly. I was stunned.

However, anyone that knows you, knows that you are sometimes a bit crass and not exactly politcally correct in your observations. An admirable quality these days. I knew then and know now that you meant no malice or harm of any kind to Mrs. Clinton, women or your viewing audience.

Tonight's apology was not necessary for the vast majority of us, we trust and admire your candor.

Thank you for 10 years of "Hardball"!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

rocco — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:26:00 GMT

RE: THIS POSTED BY KATHY RICHARDSON

Chris, I appreciate your sincerity, honesty & enthusiasm...always enjoy your show with lots of insight & truth. Please do not go overboard now with your guilt (or please, don't tell me Bill Clinton is pressuring you, too? His statement that the press was unfair to Hillary seemed incongruent with what I saw happening)and give her more breaks than Obama. I was really disappointed in your enthusiastic declaration that Clinton "won" the debate & neutralized Obama & Edwards. I hope as you analize it closer, you will see that it is Obama who always takes the high road (forgiving Clinton & her campaign for the continual unwarrented attacks; MSNBC had an excellent summary of the "racial" events, which were totally Clinton's doing), is honest (his acknowledged "weakness", which obviously has not interfered with his ability to build the best organized campaign from scratch ever seen!), is equally knowlegable & "experienced" as Clinton and is "Presidential"(an inspirational leader, intelligent, high level of integrity). He is more consistant on his positions and doesn't take PAC money like Clinton (why did Brian decide at the last minute not to allow Edwards to ask his question about pharmaceutical lobbyist money to Clinton as well? And then Brian very rudely refused to acknowledge that Obama had a question he was not allowed to ask a candidate...so Clinton had NO questions asked of her!!) And Bill Clinton wants to accuse the media of not treating Hillary fairly? The Clintons represent the politics of the past...the good ole boy (girl)favors, money, negative campaigning, corruption and half truths. Has everyone forgotten that Bill Clinton LIED to the American people? How can people trust him? In Iowa, we had a long time to get to know the candidates and their campaigns up close & personal. We got it right in Iowa...Obama will lead us to the promised land (if we all work hard!)...he is the real deal...let's not let this truly unique leader go. Please give him a fair shake!!!! He's trying to lead us on a new path & is up against great odds as he tries to beat the corporate Clinton machine.

MY REPLY:

The Clintons were the first black people in office. Im sure there were alot of people who didn't like the fact that they stood up for the minority and set up programs and laws to protect the black american. Im sure these are the same people who are now calling The Clintons Racist!!??? Look, this is not about who speaks the best who walks talk!!!as it is about getting the job done!!!! I'd rather someone lie to me about his personal life than lie to me about something else thats killing thousands of innocent people. No one died because of what bill clinton did. Oh and, there is no promise land. and it sure isn't going to come in 8yrs. not after all the mess the texan left for us to clean up..

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

RAUL ESPINOZA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:26:53 GMT

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

bob — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:31:39 GMT

Chris,

Help me understand why you and major media outlets
champion McCain as this Big war hero over being shot down over 40 years ago, but are so against the war in Iraq and haven't heard one person in the war in Iraqi
being a called a hero by you or Msnbc. Why is this?
Since I know you will not have the courage to answer this question, let me propose that both McCain and the
Gulf War & Afganistan vets are heros and you will proclaim that, or that neither groups are. Just seems
logical, unless the constant derision of the war in Iraqi and Bush and the glorification of McCain has some Political devise. This position you take makes
you look very phoney & dishonest.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

John DesMarteau, Washington, DC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:41:06 GMT

Despite your explanation it's quite clear to me and many others that you do not like Senator Clinton. Sadly my interpretation is that her gender is an issue with you. My experience tells me that people who blurt out words for which they then have to backtrack usually embrace the under lying precepts. This is a matter to which you should give considerable introspective thought.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jack from Chicago — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:41:13 GMT

Chris,
Everyone watches your program knows that you are Sen Obama's supporter. I like Barak too. But that say be carefull what you are wishing for. Within the primary no one can't really play nasty, when comes to general election, Sen Obama will be teared apart by the other side. And to think that he will be able to unite this country when he becomes the presidnet, that's just laughable. he's pro-guy, pro-life, wants to tax richer more for the economic issues, supports giving ID to illigal immigrants, on and on on many social issues ..., get reality check, people.

And to African Americans, if you think that Sen Obama will help your community more than John or Hillary will do, you may want to think hard and through, I bet he will kick you out of the bus in a hurry, just ask youself - when was he on your side? I guess you may say that you all will be very proud of him being the first African American president, that I can see that, I will be happy too. However at the end of the day, you still need to pay your bill, and hopefully you will still have a job.

One last thing, Chris, respect and fairness is the minimum requirement for a journalist, please don't lose side of that!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

D. leonard. Albuquerque, NM — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:43:38 GMT

This whole mea-culpa from Matthews, is a whitewash. Matthews has consistently said derogatory and sixist things regarding Hillary Clinton, all while attempting to build up his personal "favorites" Barack Obama and Rudy Giuliani...it's disgracefull. Chris Matthews isn't fooling anyone. Matthews has long been a political hack. He is a over-blown, over-stuffed, anti Clinton "zealot", who wouldn't know REAL politics if it fell on him. Matthews cowardly bias and attacks on Hillary, backfired in NH, and he and MSNBC were left looking the fool...hardly a new experience for Mr. Matthews. Matthews does not have the courage to admit his bias and sexisim, he instead uses a "blog" article to try and "spin" it. Cowardice is cowardice, and Chris Matthews is one of the biggest cowards in the buisness.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Phyllis Tucker — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:53:56 GMT

Hello Chris. I confess that I had never liked you and could barely watch a few minutes of your show. I did not know what you had said about Hillary Clinton, but I knew that it must have been bad, as I heard talk of it on other news networks. Tonight, however, I saw your show and heard your statements explaining what you had said about Clinton. I must say that I was very impressed and it has given me a different outlook about you. I have become a political news junkie and from now on I will try to watch your show whenever possible. Thank you for explaining how you feel.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

DCH — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:57:05 GMT

Chris,
Do not forget that one strength of the Clintons is to piss off their critics so hard that they cross the line and they can then portray themselves as victims. It worked for Gingrich and for the Republicans during the impeachment saga. They are trying to make it work for tough-love critics like yourself and others. Do not fall for it. Keep it measured.

The 10th anniversary of the Lewinsky saga is around the corner, and Democrats should be reminded of what Bill Clinton (about to be handed a 3rd term) did to bring it upon himself and stall reforms that would have served the country well. Thank you for the irreplaceable role you are playing.

DCH

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jack from Chicago — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 08:59:48 GMT

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Connie Hiaasen, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 09:07:55 GMT

Dear Chris,

Thank you so much for your comment regarding Hillary Clinton. I watch your show daily and watch Morning Joe when I can. I was taken aback when you had made the original statement and was offended. Senator Clinton is an intelligent, accomplished woman who has worked hard and overcome a lot of adversity and kept her family together. She is the first woman candidate with a real chance to win the nomination and the presidency and I do believe she is qualified and will be ready on day one. Your comment had been dismissive of her accomplishments, and I appreciate you recognizing that. Again, thank you for addressing the issue, and I look forward to following the campaigns on your show, and I hope Hillary wins it all. I also hope MSNBC returns to XM radio - I miss it!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Sean A, San Francisco, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 09:15:30 GMT

I appreciated this. I thought you were disrespectful in the original morning Joe piece, and this column rescues your show for me. I like your show, and I don't like similar shows on Fox, because you know how to get tough without stooping low.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Mr. G.D. Moore — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 09:18:04 GMT

In this election season, you are missing the unique power of a woman candidate to transform her family and her community in ways different from men. We have not seen this aspect of power in the presidency yet, but we might eh? Perhaps you might ask what Golda Meir did in Israel, or Margaret Thatcher in Britain. There is a quality which is different and engaging and it came out from Hillary Clinton for the first time in New Hampshire, when she finally lost her fear of revealing her own personality. I have observed Hillary Clinton making women proud - smiling inside. Powerful stuff.

And thank you for your mea culpa. It was due.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Marcia, Illinois — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 09:23:17 GMT

Hillary may have proven herself as a great politician, but that's not necessarily a good thing. I would like to see again the televised interview in which Hillary made a comment about not being, as I recall, 'some little stand by your man' woman. The heck she wasn't - at least publicly. While I realize that she was in a wretched situation, I continue to believe that Hillary's public position for years - even before Bill Clinton became President, further enabled him, leading up to the vulgar events which became so exhaustingly public.

I also think that Hillary has always had her eye on the future and being, I've read, every bit as smart as her Rhodes Scholar husband, had a long-term ambition to run for office. Her stand regarding her husband's behavior had to be such that it wouldn't destroy her own political possibilities.

Regarding her comments that she never doubted Bill loved her - oh, my. If she "never" doubted him, maybe she's not as smart as I have been led to believe. Or not as honest as she would like us to believe.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

M.J. Riley — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 09:27:57 GMT

In all honesty, I don't think you should have apologized. I listened to your reasons and I think you were right on target. Clinton certainly wasn't elected to the U.S. Senate in New York for her experience. She is a political animal and New York was the perfect venue to establish herself. A carpetbagger with an agenda.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Sean E. Whelan, Traverse City, Michigan — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 09:47:40 GMT

In scrolling through the points made by many posters, I sense a "holier than Thou" attitude. Anyone who has watched "Hardball" should see that no one is safe- and that is how it should be.

This blog, and this issue, is being blown beyond proportion. In analyzing politics, the whys and hows of things may not be all that pretty. It's hard denying that Hillary may have used the '98 situation as a set-up for post-White House life. And so what? She made a bad situation into a positive start for herself. I say Chris Matthews was not out of line in his remarks. Continue the good work.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Denise, Missouri City, TX — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 09:59:38 GMT

Chris,
I watch your show every day and have great respect for you and your panels of analysts. Lately, however, I have been very perturbed by the constant negative drumbeat of your somewhat personal attacks on Hillary and coronation of Barack. I need you to get back to the hard hitting analysis of ALL candidates, including Barack and Rudy who you have treated with kid gloves. I watched with sadness as you dismissed the significance of the female vote in new Hampshire and was disappointed that in an effort to explain away what happened in NH and why all the pundits and pollsters were wrong, you, in effect, nullified the message of NH voters.
I can tell you live and breathe and love politics as I do, but I don't want to feel so uncomfortable watching your show that I have to turn to CNN for political analysis! Get back to yourself, Chris. Your self-examination has made me proud.
P.S. Your best guys are Pat Buchanan and Chuck Todd. They rock!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

steve house, st michael, mn — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 10:18:19 GMT

It's always comical to see liberals eat each other-- like the demons in The Screwtape Letters. Chris Matthews deserves what he gets, in this case a humiliating dose of speech-quenching left wing fascism. Maybe now he'll realize what a mistake he's made, throwing in with this crowd. They will do whatever it takes to maintain their power, including tossing a faithful Democrat like him right over the side of the boat, if he in any way deigns to step out of line by excercising his rights. Lots more I could say, suffice it say you reap what you sow.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Donde Plowman, Knoxville, TN — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 10:25:01 GMT

Chris - I have been so angry since your initial comments about Hillary that I had hoped the network would ban you from covering the big stories in the future. It is one thing for guests to agree to come on your show, which I watch regularly, and take whatever comments you throw them. But it is another to be covering the news - the day before the vote in New hampshire - the day after the vote,etc. - and to inject such biases, and frankly what seemed like hatred of women. I can't imagine you want it to sound this way, but it seems so clear that you don't like Hillary, and not because of her views or ideologies - but because she is a woman trying to be in the game that it is ok for men to be in. Your comments rallied women voters in New Hampshire. They rallied me. I am looking forward to getting to cast my vote for Hillary on super Tuesday.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Mike Gillespie Sr. Ardmore PA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 10:40:44 GMT

Chirs: Once, I actually thought that you were the best newspaper writer in the country. Then, I though you were the best TV guy. This Hill thing has changed all of that. It isn't what you said on Morning Joe. It is all the things you have said about her over the course of this cycle. you hit her every night. Who can best lead us through this mess? She is not my prime choice. That would be Mack as we need a hero now more than ever. She would be second. You really turn me off to the point where I turn you off. You have learned how to use TV; the inflections, the eyes, etc. At times I have given you a pass, thinking you must know something we don't but that is silly because she has been vetted for 30 years. Please stop.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Tess MacGregor, Winter Park, FL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 10:41:11 GMT

Not buying it. This is more political hogwash. It wasn't just what you said on MOrning Joe - in fact what you said on that show was merely a continuation of your spew of hatred towards HRC. While you harbor such a strong dislike for the Clintons is your business - but it becomes OUR business when you continually allow that dislike to color and shape whatever political commentary you may have to make. Go back to Journalism 101 & learn about objectivity.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Linda Owens — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 10:58:29 GMT

I have been listening to alot of the election coverages and it is nothing but apparent that most if not all of the comentators that are suppost to be giving us facts, to help us make good decisions are doing nothing but giving their bias opinions. I realize every story has two sides but it doesn't take long to listen to any of you to figure out who's sides you are on. What happened to giving us just the truth and letting us make up our minds instead of all of you telling us how we should feel. Your bias shows big time. I remember when I first started following the news that I was told to only believe about 1/2 of what I read or heard, now I think I am about down to believing about 1/8th or nothing. The news no longer seems to have anything to do with the truth just the opinions of the news giver. Its sad because we should be able to rely on you. I watch the news to get informed not entertained.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dylan Kay, Dartmouth, MA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:09:16 GMT

Chris

Keep on doing what you do. I don't consider myself a fan, but I fully support your right to express an heartfelt opinion.

For those self-righteous, disingenuous, politically correct, intellectual lightweights who oppose your views on Bush, Cheney or Hillary -

Why don't you change the channel? Sounds like you prefer meaningless mumbo jumbo like 'my greatest weakness is that I am impatient' (Hillary Clinton at the Nevada debate) or 'I did not inhale'. Please, you bunch are pathetic. Stop whining and get a life.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Brandon Kitto — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:13:02 GMT

Chris, You will from this point forward always, in my book, be a putz.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Karin Williams, Winchester, VA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:17:56 GMT

Chris,
Being PC really stinks sometimes doesn't it.

You were right. You had an opinion. It was yours to openly express and MSNBC pays you well for your opinions.

However, the forum you and other "forward thinkers" move in does not allow for that. To break stride get you a backhand from all the people you previously held close as those who were just like you.

Women, just like men in the political forefront have attained their power unjustly. In Hillary's case, she has a long documented record of behaving unjustly. She doesn't need Bill's bad behavior to justify it. She just doesn't get called on it enough.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

SeedOfChange — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:27:15 GMT

This message will get filtered.

Mathews problem is not with "Clinton", it is with women and extreme sexist towards them.

It is not a single event, it is a history to sexist behavior towards co-host and guest on the show.

Fortunate for him, the sexist remark was made toward a white women, otherwise he would have faced "Imus" fate.

He should face Imus' fate. He is unacceptable on a respectable network

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Rico proud member of the VRWC, Mentor OH — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:37:32 GMT

Chris has never had a problem distorting facts, telling half truths and making biased opinions about Republican politicians. He says he loves politics and politicans, but only if they are liberal Democrats. If you want to ask a hardball question, how about this one. Would Hillary have ever gotten elected to anything if she wasn't Monica Lowenskies boyfriends wife? Time to change the name of the show from Hardball to Rolls over like a dog.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Judy Liesener, Myrtle Point, Oregon — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:40:21 GMT

Hi Chris -
Most of the time I really enjoy your show, but I've
noticed several times your tendency to border on dis-
respect toward women, and especially Hillary. I
think she's the best thing we've got going right now
in this country. After what Bush (and let's be
honest, most of the other MALE presidents have put
us through) it's right that a woman should have the
job. She's qualified, smart, experienced and yes,
Presidential. I am not voting for her because she's
a woman, but because she's all of the things I just
mentioned. You are mostly a breath of fresh air
Chris - I never watched "talking heads" until I
started watching you. And now I'm hooked! But be
fair, be aware, and listen more! You constantly
interrupt people when you've asked them a question -
I'd really like to hear them answer it. Thanks
for listening - you're a really good guy. (By the
way, what was that s__t-eatin' grin you had on your
face when Hillary patted your cheek and you hugged
her! You looked like a little boy who'd gotten
praise from his favorite teacher! Kind of endearing,
actually!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Barb K — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:46:15 GMT

I have been very annoyed and angry with all of the harsh treatment of Hillary Clinton in the media but especially Chris Matthews as she does not deserve it. Hillary is a very intelligent and hardworking individual. She did after all finish first in her Law School class at Yale. People thought she could not win when she ran for Senator in New York but she did and then won reelection with 67% of the votes. She should not be attacked for something that her husband did. Instead she should be admired for how she conducted herself during this situation. Also, the special prosecutor Ken Starr wasted over $70 million dollars of taxpayer money investigating the Clintons over Whitewater and came up with absolutely nothing. (Why isn't there a special prosecutor investigating Bush and his administration for all of the crimes they have done?) So there is nothing in her background for her to be attacked on or criticized. If it wasn't for the attack dogs of the Republican mean machine I'm sure people would stop thinking of her as being a polarizing unlikeable figure. People who know her personally describe her as a warm and very likeable person who is also very intelligent. I think she would be a great President. I also have reason to believe that Chris and NBC received many emails from women complaining about his treatment of Hillary and other females and that was the reason for this explanation but I don't see him saying "sorry".

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Gerhard Carlson — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 11:52:50 GMT

Mr Matthews: it is clear that you were right the first time. Hillary, whatever her strengths and weaknesses, does indeed play the gender card, while denying the same. The PC folks got to you. Truth is the casualty.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dave, Philadelphia — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 12:00:51 GMT

Chris,
No apology was necessary other than to salve Senator Clinton's supporters and allow Steve Capus to put his Tums back inside his desk drawer. It's obvious that the much vaunted Clinton machine is poised to frame any comment they dislike, in terms of victimhood and rouse special interest groups to do their bidding (ie Bob Johnson, Gloria S, NOW, etc). It is precisely this slickness that needs to be exposed. Since Senator Clinton seems to be running on the value of her experience on 'day one' someone has the right to question how valued her experience really is if she was a) at best a witness to history as a first lady and b) if she had no idea what President Clinton was up to with Monica, right within her own household. Mr. Obama unfortunately has to run against not only Mrs Clinton, but her husband, who seems to have the dual mission of running Senator Clinton's campaign and correcting his 8 yr record. I hope you can find a palpable way to explore the value of her experience and what it's like to campaign against President and Senator Clinton simultaneously.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Robert G, Chicago, IL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 12:22:24 GMT

Chris, given the multitude of your indiscretions and your Imus-like moments about women, your statement was inadequate. Buddy, you just don’t get it.

I tape and watch your show Monday - Friday and on Sunday. These are some of my complaints that I have personally noted:

You have made stupid comments about women. On one occasion you diminished the intellect and professionalism of a female guest by visually grimacing, rolling your eyes, and remarking on how you were so taken by her beauty. It did not belong on the air. I was glad the camera was limited to your face. You acted like a 14 year old boy about to lose it. This was unprofessional and incredibly immature.

Your treatment of Former First Lady, current U.S. Senator, and presidential candidate Hillary Clinton has been an insult to the American electoral process.

The portrait of Hillary you repeatedly use is cartoonish and insipid.

The camera shots of you and your up-close and personal hand to face Hillary moment had you in the foreground, enlarged out of perspective, and with Hillary shrunken/ diminutive/ liliputian in the background. The shot summarized your inflated ego and your diminution of and lack of respect for Senator Clinton.

Your comparison of Senator Clinton to “Nurse Ratchet.”

Your Dec 17th questioning if Hillary supporters were castrated in her service.

Your asking on Nov 17th whether Senator Clinton was a “She Devil,” picturing Senator Clinton with Devil Horns, and asking about “demonizing” Hillary. If this wasn’t an Imus moment, then what is?

Your statement that Hillary was on a short leash suggested Hillary was a female dog and subservient to a male master.

Yeah, “life is a campaign” and you are no better than those playing dirty politics on war hero and statesmen Senator John McCain.

You are the Imus of MSNBC. You are not much better than O’Reilly and no less a blow-hard. You need to straighten up or spend some time in the penalty box.

Bob G in Chicago, January 18, 2008

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Alana A., Riyadh, KSA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 12:38:51 GMT

Well-done, Chris! As a loyal fan of your show, I'd become increasingly put off by the rhetoric Hillary had been taking - not for major political gaffes, but (it appeared) more for "just existing" as a female candidate. This I didn't understand. I wrote a letter, never expecting a reply... so I was taken aback by your commentary this morning (I am in Saudi Arabia, and we receive your show the next morning)...Thank you for replying to all of us who admire you greatly, yet needed to voice our concern. You listened, and that is enough. By the way, we love your show way over here!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Linda Della Fave Monroe Twp., New Jersey — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:00:34 GMT

I have always been a fan of yours, Chris, prior to your venomous, unwarranted, attacks on Hillary Clinton. Unfortunately, your newly found bitterness is reflected on your show; I can no longer support you. Follow your heart, Chris, and stop listening to your brothers; you're much smarter than they.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Beya Adamu — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:00:43 GMT

I like your show and I watch it everyday. You said exactly what I felt about Hillary, and I hope that the Clintons did not coerce you into explaining or recanting what you said about her because you were right!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Theo Beach, Raleigh NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:02:26 GMT

Chris, Chris, Chris...can you have a show called hardball when you are wearing panties. As a conservative I watch you because you have no clue on how us in the red states think. Your show is like a bunch of limo-liberals on the upper west side discussing the back wood cretins that are in the fly over states. However, I did give you credit for being tough and sometimes coming down hard on your side..and not being PC. With Ms. Clinton however you have shown you are just an upper west side wuzz like the rest of the MSM. This is why Comedy Center fake newscast is as enjoyable as other news outlets. CC doesn't fool themselves into thinking they are journalist!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Andrine Gillis — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:04:25 GMT

I am a registered Democrat, an avid Hardball fan, and, frankly, would be happy with any of the three Democrats that are running. I do feel, however, that your bias against Hillary Clinton, and conversely, your very positive feelings about Senator Obama and your lesser feelings, although positive, about John Edwards, come to the surface more than they should as a journalist. I do not recall any negative feelings about either Edwards or Obama ever being voiced by you, but it's very difficult for you to say positive things about Senator Clinton. I too feel you have a good heart, and you are certainly entitled to your opinions off of the air, but not on it. AG, Tampa, Florida

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Vicki Chalmers, Lincoln University, Pa. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:08:02 GMT

I feel like the Clintons have really scared you to death. It was apparent when you went way over the top after the debate in declaring "Shrillery" the winner. I couldn't beleive it - neither could Hillary supporters. WOW - talk about over-compensating. Don't let the Clintons threathen you.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

FREEBladensburg Md — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:10:24 GMT

Chris is just trying to keep his job.That's all there is to it.He is a Clinton haterand disrespects women by making snide remarks.He should be removed from the air.I hope Keith does not act like that loser Chris.Norah O'Donnell,Mika and Joe are all haters.Chris Matthews should be fired.suppose someone makes the same remarks about his wife,is he gonna like it?.please make sure my comments are posted.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jeanne Mathis — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:11:12 GMT

I was unaware of Chris's latest controversial comments about Hillary and his subsequent explanation until now. Why? Because after years of faithful viewing, I finally turned the channel because of his nastiness towards some of the politicians, especially the Clintons and Hillary in particular. I am happy that I'll be able to tune him in again.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

John Dupee — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:15:40 GMT

The only person on MSNBC that appears to more full of himself than you is your cohort David Schuster. You two will probably congratulate each other if you read this.

Those that live by the sword . . .

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Karen Shinn, Littleton, North Carolina — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:22:31 GMT

I saw your first comment and I listened to your commentary last night- what apology and why? If anyone actually thinks back to the days when Clinton lied about the definition of "is" ( and before everyone gets on my bandwagon I will tell you that I voted for President Clinton TWICE!), the country rallied around Hillary and admired her for sticking with her marraige ( which I can't say I would have done). She became a much more public figure than the First Lady in the background. The whole cheating/lying episode did thrust her into the public eye, more than before. Everyone watched as she, Chelsea, and Bill walked to/from the helicopter, across the lawn, she on the one side and he on the other, with Chelsea in the middle. We felt her pain and anger at what he had done. When she got up and pulled herself up by her bootstraps in NY, people rallied to support her again. Yes, she has proven a worthy Senator for New York, but Chris, you were right on in your observations of what had taken place then and how those events catapulted her to the spotlight of political office. Chris, you have a historial perspective and insight not seen in many political analyists. You ask probing questions ( your focus on the flop of yellow cake and subsequent lying by Scooter Libby was right on) and I would urge you not to change your approach. You manage to stimulate diaglogue which is imperitive in our country today so that our citizens make better choices for the future of our country.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jennifer, Fairfield, CT — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:23:46 GMT

Chris,
I've been a faithful viewer since 206 of my friends and co-workers died in the World Trade Center on 9/11. The only real mistake you made, in my opinion, was to put too much emphasis on the theatrical side of politcs and forgot that actual policies are more influential to voters. I do however wish you had called Tom Delay out when he made the comment on Hardball about "know it all women" - his comment was real misogyny and fully deserved scrutiny. In general, my only complaint about your political coverage is that it does tend to give more weight to style - you should help to illuminate us as to policies because you really have a terrific ability to make it understandable and interesting - and poll after poll shows that we want policy coverage, not theater reviews. Horse race coverage may jazz you up but its all worthless empty calories and you can do and have done so much better. That said, you are all heart and have the best laugh on t.v. and I laughed so hard I cried when you described the tribal nature of the Republican candidates on Leno!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Rita Garcia, St. Paul, MN — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:28:59 GMT

I used to watch your show regularily. You were professional and neutral with straight talk and challenging all comers. Your comments regarding Senator Clinton demonstrate your current inability to maintain an objective perspective on politicians and this race. It was demeaning and a common form of sexism. Your coworkers are crying fowl for your being criticized. Hardball should really apply to you as well. It would though be better for you to restore your previous level of professionalism

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Chris, Bloomington, IN — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:30:40 GMT

Chris, your program is a model for what we so desperately need in the United States--an uncensored
market place of ideas. Your comments about Hillary Clinton's successful run for the U.S. Senate provided some context for the current presidential race. It
was historically accurate. Everyone complains that the media don't provide enough context for stories. Then, when an intelligent person and well-respected journalist with years of political experience (you) gives it, the offended people complain. Ignore them. We, the audience, can decide for ourselves to accept or reject your comments. Women are not victims and,
as a 54-year-old woman with a Ph.D., I'm tired of being portrayed that way. If Hillary can't take the heat, let her get out of the kitchen. Isn't that her
philosophy? Speak your mind.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Darlene Sherbondy — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:40:12 GMT

When I heard your apology last night I jumped up, pumped my fist and said YESSSS! Finally someone got to you to help you to understand the negative position you had continually taken on Hiliary Clinton. We all know your favorite is Obama, but in the future please use the airwaves in a more responsible manner and try to keep the personal bias under control. You had made watching your show painful, but I will stay with you and see how it goes.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Chris Phillips, Inverness, FL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:53:01 GMT

Chris, I did not see your comment but have watched your show frequently. I do not always agree with what you say but I feel you are sincere in your comments. It does not matter to me how you meant your reference on Hillary Clinton the simple fact is you have the right to speak your opinion. It is funny how you get chastized for your comment but others can stand on government property in D.C. and discuss killing an entire race and they are protected by hordes of police. I do not agree with what they say but I support their right to say it.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Phyllis Miller — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 13:58:34 GMT

I heard your clarification last night and appreciate the considerations that inspired it. However, I think the original comments did not go far enough.

After seeing the short clip of Hillary Clinton's "Christopher, baby" coy and flirtatious behavior toward you, I felt I was observing a person who has confusion about personal boundaries. If a male candidate had behaved in a similarly unprofessional way toward an attractive female member of the news corps, it certainly would have sparked more than a little coverage, comment, and perhaps indignation.

What I see now when I see Hillary Clinton is a woman who gains some authority and power by enabling her husband's frailties and who, herself, feels entitled to overstep other's boundaries. These character flaws are not what I want in a leader of the free world. I am of her generation, and if she is the nominee, for the first time in 40 years, I will not vote for president. Certainly, I'd love to see a woman in that office, but not like this. Not like this.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Chad, Sidney, OH. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:00:10 GMT

Sen. Clinton is tagged the victim again!
Fact is, the media has a responsibility to report situations as they see them, and Sen. Clinton has no problems dispatching the team to criticize the field, President Bush, and countless others. There is no person or group that "The Machine" would not run over to control 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.
These candidates should be judged on their work history, whether that be success or failure.
The truth is, Chris's statement is not false. The victim will carry the women's vote, and I believe it is Chris's responsibility to tell it like it is. If this one statement is more powerful than her entire campaign, and obviously someone made the call to MSNBC, then doesn't that say something for Sen. Clinton's campaign? If they cannot take this sort of criticism in the campaign, what happens if they get to the White House?
Not to take anything away from you Chris. Evidently you are more powerful than anyone on the planet! I'm glad to see this now than a year from now, if she were to win.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Tim Lovett, Fayetteville AR — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:09:23 GMT

Chris, I saw your show on Jan.17, in which you had on Allen Raymond, author of "How to Rig an Election: Confessions of a Republican Operative". In his opening statement, he admitted to entering into a criminal conspiracy with an as yet unnamed "agent of the RNC". This seems like a big story to me. Who is the agent of the RNC that hired Raymond to illegaly jam the Democrats phone lines in New Hapmshire? And did you ask him about this? Of course not! You wanted to know what he thought about the CEO of BET saying that Hillary was helping black people when Barak was hangin out in the neighborhood! Good God, Chris! You don't think criminal conspiracy to commit election fraud by as yet unnamed RNC officials is newsworthy?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Bill Camarda — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:17:32 GMT

I am not impressed. Yet. You apologized for one comment. But you have also said Clinton resembled Nurse Ratched. You have alluded to her as a she devil. You have suggested that if a candidate surrounds herself with women, that candidate undermines his or her case to be commander in chief. You have likened Clinton to a strip teaser. You have doubted aloud whether she a "convincing Mom." You called her "a sort of a Madame Defarge of the left." And when you met her in person, you pinched her cheek. You may not have even realized it, but this is the language and the behavior of someone who is interested in belittling and debasing others based on their sex. Period. Make your argument based on facts and issues, if you can. For all the candidates, of both parties. THEN I'll believe you have the goodwill you SAY you have.

Clinton is about my eighth choice for President. I'm no fan of hers. But the way you have treated her -- not just once, but over and over again, for years -- is unconscionable.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Colleen, Ithaca, NY — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:19:11 GMT

Chris,
I watch your show everyday. I appreciate that you wear your heart on your sleeve and that you often have little control over your passions. I've also learned to appreciate the metaphors you use, which enable you to quickly and effectively make a point. Sometimes you may come off as a little insensitive, but I would be disappointed if you suddenly started to censor yourself.

In addition to the Hillary comments, I've seen you flatter female guests in a way that most men in your position would probably avoid. I consider myself a feminist, but I do not wish to muzzle all men who are charmed by the presence of an attractive woman. I actually find it refreshing - we're all human. Men and women have got to learn to accept and respect our differences.

Don't go changin' Chris!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Reed — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:20:50 GMT

I used to enjoy watching Hardball. Chris Matthews rude obsession with Hillary Clinton turned me off. I no longer watch the program.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

ED WINTER PARK FL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:25:57 GMT

Chris I have watched you and the other talking heads for years and the main mission that comes across from any of you [Except Orielly whose ego is one of a pompous ass at all times]is to spout any thing that will get you a passable audience to retain your position or job. All of you will say anything no matter how real or fair to get ratings high enough to continue in your pursuits of self admiration. You have a continual habit of shouting and interfering with any or all guests and frequently lately it is more enjoyable to switch to any other channel including spanish language which i do not understand as i usually do not understand your ranting and raving my hopes are to see you traded or given to fox news as your type of interaction would fit in with Oreiily and Hannity.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

hilda mackenzie wallingford ct — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:27:15 GMT

I think you (Chris) spend too many minutes on hammering Hillary and I am glad you were called on it the next one to be called is Tucker...Just how important to you think you two are?? I like your show but you have become too cockty and arrogant and you never give others a chance to speak.. Be informative and be fair...you are not on Fox

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

C.Myles — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:29:04 GMT

Matthews' comments were FAR less innocent than a dozen that Hillary has shouted about Obama....and FAR more accurate that what she has spouted. The Clintons love to spread inaccurate details about other candidates, but hate to hear the truth about themselves.She is governed by a plan to be divisive, and untrustworthy. I am shocked that a single African American would vote for her.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

David S, Columbus, OH — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:29:07 GMT

'Bout time Chris. Obviously you have been in 'love' with Obama for the past few months. It is VERY, VERY tiresome to hear you trash Hillary Clinton every night. Your outbursts of laughter ('Ha!')over all of your negative spin on Hillary is crazy; we were having to check the channel to make sure we were not tuned into FOX news! Please continue giving us, and Hillary, a break...

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Patricia Bean — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:29:15 GMT

I stopped watching Hardball two weeks ago. His apology has not altered my decision.

Former avid Hardwall watcher!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

George Kalogridis — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:30:18 GMT

The purpose of a blog is unfettered public opinion.

You did not post my critical response last night to Chris's lame apology and I sure you've kept many more negative post from appearing.

This blog is a sham

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Kathy, Peoria, IL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:40:04 GMT

Chris I am an avid Hardball watcher. I do not know who I am voting for yet...I am completely undecided at this point, but I do consider myself a moderate democrat. I am not a feminist nor am I a member of a left wing organization (don't even go to their web sites). I am a common ordinary midwest woman voter whose favorite cable network is MSNBC. I watch you, I watch Joe and I watch Keith. However, I have noticed how much Hillary bashing goes on on your show. Even though I don't plan to vote for Hillary, I don't like the Hillary bashing. It gets old and everything you say is negative about her. Women notice this.

As I was driving to work this morning, I thought to myself that if I were to vote for Hillary, I would not be voting for her out of "sympathy" as you state the women of New Hampshire did, but I would be voting for her because I think she is "courageous and has guts" (just as you have described McCain). I think Hillary has those same attributes for what she went through. Only you describe it as a "sympathy" issue and I describe it as a "courage" issue. And if I were to vote for her...it would be that I respect her for her "courage"...not because I feel sorry for her.

The first thing that stood out to me when I saw your apology was that McCain was described by you as courageous....Chris...I don't see Hillary as a victim as you do...I see her as a courageous woman who overcame a lot of adversity....just as John McCain has overcome adversity. Men aren't the only ones who are courageous.

I think you should have apologized...many of us are offended by some of the things you say. And this was an appropriate time to try and get an apology out there. An "I'm sorry" would have been nice, but at least you have made this effort. I respect you for that. I'm hoping Hardball will be a lot more pleasant to watch because of what has happened. You said "I get it," in your apology. If you mean that, that can only make Hardball better.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Allison, New York, NY — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:41:37 GMT

Chris,

Why did you have to apologize to Hillary? Just because Gloria Steinham (who I happen to like) misconstrued what you said on Morning Joe was no reason to make such a public mea culpa.

I heard Mika and Joe discussing it today and I totally agreed with them. Just because Hillary supporters don't like that you were speaking that truth, namely that she has used the Lewinsky scandal and played the "sympathy card" several times to get her senate seat and to win NH, doesn't make it any the less true.

Continue to speak the truth, Chris. We need someone to do that!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Risa Peoples — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:42:00 GMT

Chris: Women cry more than men. It's rarely manipulative and it isn't a sign of weakness. It's just biology. Joe Scarborough's mom seemed like the only one around who understood what happened in New Hampshire. I think that it was not sympathy for her tears, but our anger at the press reaction that got all those women- uncomitted and/or not likely voters on Saturday- out to the polls for Mrs. Clinton on Tuesday. I hope you give your pre-New Hampshire shows another look. I'm a Barak supporter, but even I was rooting for her after your shows. If you guys respond like this again, you're going to hand her the election.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

David, New Braunfels, TX — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:42:17 GMT

I see Mr. Matthews make frequent ridiculous statements about individuals of all stripes.....men, women, black, white, left and right. Seems he only needs to apologize when the Clinton's are involved. I guess Hillary does have a lockbox. I find it entertaining now that Bill and Hillary are experiencing what every other politico normally receives, and now they are crying foul as they are used to dishing it out and receiving a pass from the media.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dinsdale, Wichita Falls, Texas — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:42:38 GMT

The apology was as pathetic as Chris himself. Of course Hillary is where she is because of Bill. The people of New York would have run her out on a rail had she not been carpetbagging as the former first lady. Her candidacy is a joke, she is nothing more than another recycled socialist, and it speaks to the general stupidity of this nation that she actually has a decent chance of being elected president. We are a nation of idiots who will believe anything. I'm stil waiting for Chris to ask a tough question of any of the candidates. It won't happen though, he's too big a wimp to state the obvious anymore, as evidenced by his capitulation to the Clintons.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

PW Greeneville SC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:44:20 GMT

Chris Matthews is a loud-talking head whose opnions are unimportant!!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

jason smith, upstate ny — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:44:40 GMT

There are a lot of double standards surrounding Hillary Clinton. The GOP tear each other apart and don't break down crying. People underestimate how much Hillary's career depended on her staying with her cheating husband....who was impeached and has no right to even be campaigning....

Instead of feminists being insulted Hillary would lower herself for political reasons to the shameless behavior of staying with a cheating husband, instead of leaving and saying she doesn't need him....they are somehow happy that she has done a disservice to all empowered women.....

Hillary cannot expect to take cheap shots at other candidates and then not expect others to not defend themselves.....she is an expert at "spin".....that much is true.....we don't need more of that kind of experience.....

Other countries have women prez. and vp's...and it is not even an issue...because they actually have a job to do.....and they have more self-respect to break down and cry, or blame others.....

"Political correctness" in this country is stifling any open discussion about anything.....if Hillary can't take it, don't attack others and don't run for President...."

"Vote For Monica's Cheating Husband's Wife For President '08"

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Gerald Hench Lexington Ky. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:48:14 GMT

It was bigotry, plain and simple. Chris is no different than the right wing mad dogs when it comes to Hillary, or the idea of a powerful woman or a woman president. Now he can try and reform himself. We'll be watching.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Elizamary, dover de 19962 — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:48:51 GMT

yeah well, a little too late with the apology. Chris mathews has already proven he is a jerk.
I think he should be kicked of the air. he is an arogant SOB

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Anne Paye, R.S.M. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:50:34 GMT

Chris, I disagree with your explanation of why people voted Hillary Clinton into the Senate, which seems to be based on your obvious bias against women. I believe she was chosen because she is very intelligent and is supportive of the needs of average Americans. Why can't "Hardball" be played fairly?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Judy, St. Louis, Mo — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:52:04 GMT

Chris,
I am a huge fan of yours because you ask the tough questions and you don't fall for the spin of the politicians. However, I was disappointed to hear the Suck up, make up, to the Clintons. I hope you did not fall to pressure, that's not like you!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

M. Gilpin, Austin, Tx — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 14:58:40 GMT

You are too smart to make such a statement carelessly. Maybe tabloid journalism has just rubbed off on you to such an extent that it sounded too chic and too cutsey to pass up. You lost me with that interview.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dawlish — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:02:30 GMT

I used to watch Hardball a few years back.. i stopped after i saw how excited you were when President Bush 's photo op of " Mission Accomplished" I thought when seing how excited you were Chris is a smart guy.. he has no idea about how the middle East work.. this is not finished yet( i lived 6 years in the Middle EASt and i knew that the hatred that the average arab male has for the US policies in the ME would lead to sustain insurgency and it has in Iraq)

You are a good man Chris... you have to appear to be fair.. your excitement about Barack Obama and your desdain of the Clintons and lack for respect for Ms Clinton is so palpable it is sickening.. Did you apologize to Ms. Clinton? Stop pushing Obama down our throat.. let us make up our minds

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Paul Fraser — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:05:49 GMT

Clinton will win despite all of the vitriol spewed at her and believe me folks a new era will dawn in american politics. I know she won't, but I would hope that she would take Obama as her running mate. With that combination we will be assured of 16 more years of a democratic (sane) presidency.

As far as I'm concerned, the republicans have lost their mandate of heaven forever. Their brutish aggresiveness and callous disregard for the bill of rights has forever disqualified them from being anywhere near the nuclear trigger.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jim McCarthy — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:07:09 GMT

Chris, don't beat yourself up. Hillary realiizes that period of her life will be used by others as a negative. Your comment reveals a personnal inner strength of a public figure. You have always tried to show a different views of a candidate. I am retired, and my wife and I watch your show every night. Not sure you think that is a plus, since I also watch Imus. Not sure that your present position allows,but I would like to hear you again on his show.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jason, New Haven, CT — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:10:06 GMT

Chris,

I used to watch your show faithfully. But not any more. Somehow I feel that you want to be a King maker. And that colors your comments to a great extent. Honestly, I am not suprised that you said what you said about Hillary, coming from you doesn't surprise me. I am not a Hillary fan, but she has gained my respect over the past few months. I was rooting for Edwards in the beginning and still hope that he will do better. As to Obama, I have always wanted to root for him. But he hasn't given me enough to root for. After the past 7 years, I so much want a competent president, I don't have to like him or her. I still remember how you praised President Bush to the skies because he looked so good in that uniform while pronouncing "missing accomplished." He did look good, I will give you that, but I have always thought it takes more than that to be a predisent.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Kathy Pelland, Concord, New Hampshire — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:11:48 GMT

Your comments about Hillary made me very angry. I don't really have an opinion about her but I felt you were unjustly harsh towards her personally. I was glad to see you address the comments on your show last night. But why did Joe Scarborough get so angry about your apology this morning? Doesn't that defeat the purpose of it? So he apologizes and then his colleagues get angry that he apologized. I don't think I'll be watching MSNBC anymore. You are starting to sound like FOX News.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Michael D. Hafer, Fort Wayne, Indiana — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:16:27 GMT

Chris Matthews - You are my favorite TV news personality. You have NOTHING to apologize for. Rabid feminists took your comments out of context, bitched about it on that vapid show "The View" and made you into the poster boy for misogyny, when clearly you are a good guy who made an honest an accurate political commentary of Hillary Clinton's rise to power. I am a Democrat and a strong believer in equal rights for all, but everything you've said about Hillary Clinton has been accurate and concise, based upon the facts, her statements and mistatements, and the political reality in which we all find ourselves.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Gary L., Stafford Virginia (R) — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:18:35 GMT

If you read these comments, please disregard the morons that put you down. Intelligent people could understand what you meant by your comments and Clinton supporters look for any way they can to cry "foul!"

Keep fighting the good fight and calling 'em like you see 'em. You're loved for your honesty and your ability to cut to the heart of the matter. Please don't ever change because of what the ignorant majority say. You're a national treasure.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Sandy, Louisville, KY — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:18:55 GMT

Statements like this from Chris Matthews confirms my decision to STOP watching him. He was once again way out of line. Always lets his mouth run away with him. I have always been amazed that MSNBC let him get by with the derogatory comments he has makes and his outright dislike of someone being televised. Not only was it insulting to the person, his comments are very disrepectful and he should be above that type of behavior considering his position at MSNBC. Sometimes it is best to keep our mouth shut and our own personal feelings to ourselves. This election is not about the candidate Chris Matthews endorses, although everyone can guess which person from both parties he excites him. Maybe Chris Matthews needs to seek another profession....doesn't MSNBC remove people from the air who make derogatory remarks about individuals? Seems like I remember not so long ago....may be that is exactly what should happen in this instance.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Patrick Briggs, Pasadena, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:19:06 GMT

Your apology and clarification is no less insincere than most of your work. It's why I gave up watching these "news" talk shows a long time ago.

Your work serves the beltway, not the people, and is a tragic example of the depths our media has fallen.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Michael D. Hafer, Fort Wayne, Indiana — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:21:23 GMT

Darcy Gagnon: Matthews has been VERY hard on the Bush Administration in the past. Open YOUR eyes. Matthews has been in this business for years. He sees the kind of slimy tactics and dirt bag politics that infects the system. He calls it as he sees it and that's why I am a loyal viewer.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Chuck Flory, Princeton NJ — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:21:52 GMT

Chris,
I appreciate the work you do, and the Hardball show. While many times I do not agree with your opinions, one of the things I have always liked about the show is your willingness to walk the edge, to be provacative, and to give air, either yourself or through your varied guest, to the many sides of these touchy issues. In retrospect, as you say, the comments on Hillary were insensitive, and came off wrong, but I, for one, do not ascribe wrong intentions to them. Your point, as qualified above, was a fair observation, pooly phrased. All consumers of shows such as yours must view these shows with some sensitivity to the role of a person who puts himself/herself out in the position you do, daily, talking about such highly charged issues, with no scirpt, just a heart to guide them through these minefields. Who among us has not made an insensitive comment, or formed a wrong opinion on the spot, when discussing such topics. The difference is the vast majority of us do it in a far less public forum, and the repurcussions are far less. I salute you and all others who are willing to actually say something of value in the wasteland that is TV in year 2008. It is not easy in the post Imus world, where one misstep can lead to a career threatening crisis.

Keep up the good work.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Joe Crutchfield, Centralia, Wash. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:22:58 GMT

Chris, I have watched you for a long time and have been turning off your program more and more. The comparison between your viciousness against Hilary Clinton and you and G G Liddy praising the way the Bush crotch was framed during his carrier landing was the most telling comment on your attitudes toward women I have ever seen.
Perhaps your apology was sincere--I don't know. I suspect if it was, you will repeat the offense within the next couple of weeks.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Ronne Denn, Florida — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:25:26 GMT

I am a very strong and vocal proponent of you and your program, actually switched from CNN mostly because of you, and now Morning Joe, BUT your obvious dislike of the Clinton's and your obvious delight in Obama can be unsettling. I am a political junkioe and luv watching the back and forth, glad u felt the desire to look at your "old" notions of womanhood and our achievements.
Still luv u tho

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Beth Pyles, McDowell, Virginia — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:26:57 GMT

Dear Mr. Matthews,
At this time, I do not intend to vote for Hilary Clinton, but the fact is that I have spent many days after watching Hardball asking myself if you and others understand that the recurring sexism actually pushes me to support her out of my own anger and frustration at your words.
I am a woman voter and I do not care about whether Mrs. Clinton's pearls are satisfactory; I do not care about claims that she has shown cleavage inappropriately on the Senate floor; I do not care whether her calves are too large in the judgment of Ann Coulter. And I do not care what part you think her role as the 'wronged wife' played in her Senate victory in New York.
Not only is it speculative and dismissive, it is irrelevant to the issues at hand.
The problem is that you have become, from where I am sitting, a repeat offender. Whenever an attractive woman (in your view) appears on your show, you make remarks about her appearance. All I learn from these remarks is how to discern which women you find attractive and which you do not.
These are serious times and there are too few places on mainstream media where concerned citizens can turn for serious analysis of the issues of the day. I used to think your show was such a place, but because of your barely concealed enmity towards Mrs. Clinton, expressed in terms of abject sexism, I had decided not to watch your show anymore.
Given your apology, I'll give it another try.
But please understand that your words did not 'seem' dismissive to some women; your words were dismissive.
Your listening public deserves better from you.
A practical suggestion might help: stop calling Senator Clinton 'Hilary'. It's a common happenstance across the media spectrum. Linguists and parents understand the importance of words. If you do not refer to all the presidential candidates by their first names (and you do not), then do not refer to Senator Clinton that way. Given your obvious dislike of the Senator, it only adds further insult to an already-dismissive posture.
Just a suggestion from a woman who is not particularly overly-sensitive, but who is old enough to remember how far we claim to have come in putting aside sexist attitudes in our country.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Laura Green, White Hall, MD — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:27:09 GMT

Dear Chris,

My husband and I watch you every night and rely on your good heart and fine mind. We know that you ment to disrespect to Hillary. It is amazing that you are able to do your difficult job so beautifully in the heat of every Hardball broadcast. You are a great man. Or rather, you are great, man!
Funny that your show is called, "Hardball", but we bet that you are actually a "softie" at heart. But then, you have a wise and strong wife behind you. Ah, that is another story! Keep up the excellent work, Chris.
Martin & Laura Green
White Hall, MD

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Scott from Ahwatukee, AZ — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:29:14 GMT

It really bothered me that he was asked to make this "apology". Clinton has constantly remarked that she is the most vetted candidate, well this is part of being vetted. The whole story of her being the poor victim is out there in the public domain, it's not like the Clintons were powerless in the events of ten years ago. Shame on MSNB for forcing Mathews to apologize for saying what so many people are really thinking.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Mike Varner, Las Vegas, NV — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:30:57 GMT

You call it as you see it and you got hammered, admit that. Hilary has 35 years experience. 8 years as first lady. She didn't know what Bill was up to, where the billing records where in her white house office, etc. You were right on without Bill, there is no NY senate seat. job at a law firm in AK. we know how education improved in that state, poor people income rose, better jobs to the state - not.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Roseanne Varner, Las Vegas, NV — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:35:05 GMT

Flip, flop. You were right and you backed down because it was Hilary and the access to the DEm machine that sat on your chest. Everyone knows your word were true. Go to Fox, you can say what you want and I will be watching and listening...

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Deborah Hanan, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:43:33 GMT

Your remarks about Clinton were part of a pattern, in which you have been shamelessly promoting Obama and McCain as candidates and ruthlessly diminishing others, particularly Sen Clinton. So to me, this mea culpa reads as a hollow attempt to save your own poll numbers. You did not just alienate women with your remarks, my own 82 year old father (whose is not exactly the most enlightened person in the world when it comes to sexism) was appalled by the way you've discussed her over the last month and a half. As for myself, I was not vocal about supporting Clinton until I saw your repeated sexist attacks on Hardball. Now I feel it is imperative to remind my friends and associates to focus on the issues, including the fact that it is still seemingly permissable to attack people on the basis of gender. By the way, we who respond this way are not being "sensitive" as you say, you are being a chauvinist. Therefore, if you really want to fess up, let's start there.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

ll minneapolis mn — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:46:43 GMT

Chris, your comments show that you totally don't get it. It isn't just your rude and dismissive tone toward Senator Clinton, it is your attitude about women in general that I find not only reprehensible, but creepy. The time you told one of the women (Erin? I don't remember her name) to come closer to the camera was about as sexist a thing as I have seen. To blame your "enthusiasm for politics" is disingenuous at best. You do have an attitude about Senator Clinton that is agenda driven, your whole show has become nothing more than Matthews Republican rant. You are rude to your guests, and I can't imagine why anyone would participate in your show. It is time for you to go, and I would like to see you replaced by someone that has a brain cell operating. A woman, Mika perhaps. You should be fired just like Imus was.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Linda Bridges Hot Springs Ar. — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:48:20 GMT

I have watched your show for years, but have stoped because you are to one sided. I heard about your remark on C_SAPN. I would like to see if you have the hardballs to say Obama is where he is only because he is black.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Lonny Ponte Vedra Beach FL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:48:59 GMT

Mathews has been "over the top" lately and his dismissive disgust of the Clintons has been part of his trade mark for years!It is one thing to not like the Clintons but another to be so blatant, and ugly about his advocacy. I generally watch the show -- but lately I have turned it off. When he gets his ego under control and becomes less insulting -- I'll try him again.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Maureen Schmude, Dumont, NJ — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:49:51 GMT

I've looked at Hardball for a number of years, but Chris Matthews hyper behavior has become obnoxious. When he asks a question, he should wait for the answer. Much of the time, he is ranting above the guests' answers. The show is like a circus.
I'm thankful for Keith Obermann.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jillian — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:50:45 GMT

I'm sorry, but I'm not going to let you off the hook so easy. I'm very happy that finally somebody said something, because your behavior has been so offensive the past couple of months.

I don't think you're rooting for the people of this country if you refuse to listen to them. Even if it's only the housewives of this country who end up voting for Hillary. Their vote is still important. You weren't only dismissive of Hillary's achievements, but you were trying to be dismissive of all who voted for her in New Hampshire. And that's not rooting for the American people.

I'm not surprised you didn't apologize. YOu're far to arrogant for that.

I think you need to take a trip back to Journalism school and while you're at it take a women's studies class. Believe me you will be taught more in the latter then the former. That will be your legacy unfortunately if you keep this up.

I only hope you don't treat the women in your life like this.

Find out what your personal grudge is toward Hillary and stop using "gender specific" comments when discussing her stand on issues that you claim are so important to you.

You don't have to sell out or be offensive like Bill O'Reilly and Rush Limbugh to get ratings.

I watched Morning Joe this morning and they called it censorship. It's not censorship. You are a member of the press.

No one is taking issue with you challenging Hillary Clinton in issues- they are taking

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

BubbaDownSouth — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:51:29 GMT

Chris,
You should produce your show and try to sell it to the networks, instead of having MSNBC pay all of the costs, including your salary. You can say anything you want, until your advertisers pull their support and then you are cancelled whether you clarify or not.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Michael D. Hafer, Fort Wayne, Indiana — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:52:53 GMT

I like Matthews precisely because he isn't 100% professional 100% of the time. I have a real sense that he realizes what a charmed position he has and that he's lucky he gets to take part in it. I find him like a political fanboy that has a seat at the table and is unapologetically happy to be there! I see nothing wrong with him complimenting his female guests on how they look. Its humanizing, NOT dehumanizing. His recent interview with Elizabeth Edwards was stellar! He asked the tough questions of her and her husband's candidacy and didn't back down, and at the end of the interview he gave her a genuine warm smile, which was returned by Elizabeth, and he complimented her on her amazing smile and how GREAT of a woman she was. She was gracious and he was gracious. Similarly, he gave Hillary Clinton a hug after grilling her at a news conference. Would he give a male politician a hug? Probably not. Is he a misogynist who treats women as second class citizens? Get real! He always treats his female guests and fellow commentators (like AB Stoddard, Nora O'Donnell, etc.) with respect and professionalism, but at the end of the day, they're all human beings! Why not a wink and nudge and a "ha ha"? His show isn't a "news cast" anyway. Tongue-in-cheek is part of the Matthews appeal and is widely known. Besides, the women he has on his show are all strong confident women. They can handle themselves. Find a new bandwagon to ride, people.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Sheila, Connecticut — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:56:03 GMT

Chris:
I have been stunned by the bias you show against Hillary Clinton. Whether you like her personally or not, as a journalist you have an obligation not to try and tip public opinion against a candidate you obviously do not like. My husband is apolitical but has commented several times while I have been watching your show "He really doesn't like the Clinton's does he?".

I think Hardball is a great show, but am getting increasingly turned off by the lack of balanced reporting.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jim Hickland Laurel Springs, NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:56:32 GMT

It's pretty remarkable when Pat Buchanon has a more objective view of Hillary Clinton than Hardball's host. It's pretty clear that Matthews hates the Clinton's, but can't bring himself to admit it. Frankly - I believe Matthews has gone Hollywood. He obviously thinks he's special - bright, witty, and omniscient. He's not any of these, in reality, he's merely grown obnoxious!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Bernice K — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 15:58:50 GMT

Chris,

It would be good if you went back and looked at how you describe the same events differently depending on who's involved. You use positive adjectives for men -
aggressive, forceful, confident and negative adjectives for women, shrill, cackle, arrogant, grating and contrived.

I too enjoyed watching you until you're sexism really turned me off. I'm hopeful you can change but I'm not sure you really want too.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Fred Hetzer, Lahaina, HI — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:00:24 GMT

Dear Chris,
I think you are right on relative to the reason Hilary was elected a senator. It could have been stated a little more diplomatically, but the truth is the truth. Thanks for telling it like it is, there was no need to apologize. We are being taken over by the "politically correct" minority, they just need to get over it and stop being so full of themselves.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

truthnmedia — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:04:08 GMT

Oberman is so much better thn matthews, Keith runs MSNBC. he is the man

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Chris, Norman, OK — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:06:06 GMT

Why are so many people acting so upset when Chris Matthews was just pointing out that Hillary Clinton will never be able to separate herself from her husband and his own legacy? Hillary fans want her experience as First Lady to count as political experience but not that she used a crisis to benefit her politically? Stop trying to put a halo on a politician--it's that kind of thinking that's allowed many to give the current president a free pass on so much of what he wants to do.

And when we hold a critic such as Matthews to a high standard, that is good because he has a prominent voice in the media. But we should not refuse to hold ourselves to some standard simply because we have a smaller voice and use it on a blog. Some who have replied on here have said things that are quite out of place themselves, even acting as if the entire conversation should be a men vs. women affair in all of politics.

The fact is that much of the country's first impressions of Hillary come from not just her fight for health care but also the silly public debate about her hair styles and yes, of course, her reaction to her husband's affair and subsequent impeachment. When we have a critic such as Matthews who loses the freedom to state the obvious (from the summary above he did not say it was solely due to her reaction), we the people lose a valuable watchdog and it is we the people who ultimately lose.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Stella/New Jersey — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:08:05 GMT

Both you and Keith were obnoxious after Hillary's victory in New Hampshire.I was leaning towards her, but your reactions pushed me over.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Chris K., Cedar Park, TX — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:14:34 GMT

Chris,

Your comments about Sen. Clinton were insensitive. That doesn't make them wrong.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Manuel, San Diego, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:14:40 GMT

I was turned off by your comments, but your explanation is enough...it comes through as very sincere.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Dan Palmer, Santa Monica, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:15:02 GMT

Chris,

Just keep giving it straight, and don't worry about the reaction of the politicians or their campaigns. When your criticisms and observations are valid, it will be painful for them to hear. As long as you tell the truth as you honestly see it, and they can respond for themselves, you are playing fair. Let the chips fall where they may.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Frank Gentile, Newington, CT — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:21:03 GMT

Chris -

Your original comment was absolutely correct. If her name was "Joan Smith", she would never be running for president.

She is an opportunist - why else would she have run for Senate from New York instead of Arkansas or Illinois.

You have nothing to apologize for

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Melinda, Charlotte, NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:21:03 GMT

I used to be a huge Hardball fan, and I still am; however, Chris Matthews went way, way over the line on his show regarding Hillary Clinton. I watched all night during the New Hampshire primary coverage, and the vitriol he was spewing about Hillary Clinton turned by stomach. He is right to apologize, and I think that anyone who watches the show all the time like I do could not fail to notice his discrimination toward Senator Clinton. I am not saying he feels that way because she is a woman, but I have never seen such distorted coverage. It has eased up considerably, and I feel much better about watching the show. Readers, make no mistake...Matthews was heavily biased against the junior senator from New York. Let's move on and play fair.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

J, Ca — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:21:35 GMT

This is not the first or only time Mathews has made anti-feminist comments. I remember one time he said with reference to Hillary's voice that When a woman raise her voice it is unpleasant to ears unlike when a man raise his.Chris Mathewes has a particular hatre towards Clintons. Hillary being a woman gives more reason for him to hate her.I think it's time he leaned his lessons.Chris Mathews is operating an anti-clinton Mafia in MSNBC. For instance, look what they are doing today to hide poll results of Nevada caucus where Hillary's leading in all, by putting SC primary polls over and over agian.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Ron Borowski, Waukesha, WI — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:22:03 GMT

Chris,
Groveling and apologizing for what you said about Hillary Clinton! What hypocrisy. When does all the Liberal PC stuff stop? Since when is the truth and factual comments not acceptable. You disappoint!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Audrey June, Vancouver Island, Canada — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:25:13 GMT

It seems to me that Bill Clinton is trying very very hard to become President again - thru his wife. I don't know why you pundits don't get on the "Dual Double Whammy Clinton Presidential Campaign" being cast against Barack Obama and John Edwards. (I hardly call that fair). Also, dont sell yourself short on Hillary Clinton - look at her response on Fox Network about her tearful moment "I have liberated women so they can become human beings in politics" - Tucker has this tape. The absolute arrogance to think that she liberated anyone. Benazir Bhutto was assassinated; Indira Ghandi was in politics long before Hillary Clinton was even thought of; Margaret Thatcher was a leader. These are all female politicians - there are hundreds of women leaders throughout the World and they didn't require liberation from Hillary Clinton.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

JD, Canton, IL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:28:29 GMT

Chris,

Bottom line is that politicians draw on all their experiences to get elected. What was an unfortunate and difficult time for HRC, still became part of her and she used it well. That's politics.

The reason I am an avid watcher of Hardball is the spontaneity of the moment. I don't watch for political correctness. Keep it up! No apologies necessary.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

LR — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:30:28 GMT

Well, "Noballs" has sunk to a new low. I guess it's bound to happen, now that you report to Keith and live in fear of his sillness. Maybe, just maybe,you should have called up Lizzy Edwards, since it's her role to defend the balless.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Limo, Parkersburg, WV — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:32:26 GMT

My husband and I use to watch Chris until the New Hampshire election night. We will never watch him again. He is just a mouth inwhich someone should tape shut. His opinion is no more important than anyone elses. We also noticed after watching Keith Oberman lately that he brought some of Hardball over to his show..he played Hillary's sob three or four times that night and never once played W's sob that day. Give us a break..you also have Joe in the morning pushing Obama..those people think they can select the people to run in the election. We all have a mind of our own...and by the way they selected the goof we've had for eight years!! BEST FOR EVERYONE TO STOP WATCHING MSNBC!!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

barb, Berkeley, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:33:35 GMT

Chris
I am a fan and I appreciate you thinking through what you said. Thanks

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Joe Wawrzyniak, York Beach, Maine — Thu, 14 Feb 2008 23:55:38 GMT

Chris, why is it when someone has an opinion that isn't part of the Clinton-wave, they have to apologize for their opinions? When has an American's opinion have to fit the Clinton mold? She's doing this a lot lately. Is she that frightened of losing her ability to intimidate good people? She has way too much authority in the media.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Lisa, Minneapolis, Minnesota — Fri, 15 Feb 2008 08:24:56 GMT

Chris,
I am a 46 year old college educated middle class woman from Minneapolis. I think that you would find it interesting that if Obama wins the general election I will, for the first time in my llife, vote for a republican. I think he is the Emporer who had no clothes...all talk and no solution. This whole thing is simply a reaction to GWBush and his failed presidency...nothing else.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Michele, Baltimore, Maryland — Fri, 15 Feb 2008 14:25:23 GMT

Chris, hank you for finally saying what everyone else was thinking. However, in retrospect, Bill Clinton's impeachment probably led to the election of a Republican of GW Bush's caliber. I do believe that Hilary has benefited from her 'victim' role. I as a woman have also sympathized with her. But Bill's pre-South Carolina primary comments have erased all sympathy and empathy I had for Hilary. There is no way the Clintons belong back in our Nations highest office. America needs to turn the page and move on.

Chris, no apology was necessary. Keep on doing what you do; for each lost viewer - you have probably gained two. I remain a loyal fan.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Rose Sias — Fri, 15 Feb 2008 15:08:33 GMT

Chris, you are my guy, I enyoy watching your show, but I am puzzled by the fact that no one has made mention of the fact, that since Hillary Clinton is experiencing so many problems running her campaign, why should anyone grant her privilege of becoming the president of this great country? She has people leaving, personnel being shuffled, and just utter chaos. She can cast as many aspersions towards Obama, but we have not heard of anyone leaving his campaign, or him having to write himself a check. Obama is a very smart man, and it is apparent that he has put together a great organization. And, he knows how to surround himself with smart and dedicated people.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Rosemary, California — Fri, 15 Feb 2008 21:00:18 GMT

Chris, I am sorry I don't think you owed Clinton an apology. What you said on Morning Joe was exactly correct. Why is it when people speak the truth finally coming from you guys it is a problem. I have heard you often speak of Sen. Obama as skating into his Senate seat because his opponents imploded and that he was not really tested. Well so did Hillary's for her first run. It was a sympathy vote. Rudy had prostate cancer and he was keeping a mistress in the house with his current wife. Bill's philandering and the public felt she deserved something for putting up with him. So yes, she skated to an easy victory. So maybe you should apologize to Sen. Obama also for saying that he won an easy victory.

But like I said at the beginning of this comment. I don't feel you owe her any kind of an apology. I guess there are still people out there who are afraid of the Clintons. I hope the voters in this country will tell them they are not and thank them for their Presidency in the 90's and move on. Just like Bill told George Bush 1 in a debate, we want to thank you for your service to the country, but it is time to move on.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

judy grandits — Sat, 16 Feb 2008 00:35:42 GMT

Re Obama vs Clinton
What the people want? Change in Washington! We want noncombative people. Have we not dealt with"schoolyard" behavior long enough? We're looking for integrity first! Hense, Obama vs McCain sounds fine to me. Wahington looks like a day care center.
Give us credit for noticing!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Manuel Rodriguez, Yuma, AZ — Sun, 17 Feb 2008 06:28:36 GMT

Chris, your belated apology is accepted.Hillary is every bit as tough as McCain and she would make mincemeat of both Obama and McCain in any one on one debates.Guys who feel they can not vote for a woman
should have the guts to tell their Moms, wives, sisters ,etc.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Rick, san antonio, TX — Sun, 17 Feb 2008 15:50:34 GMT

Chris, I like your show, but I hate when you go negative on a candidate, like you do with Hillary. Let the people make their own choice and stop being so anti Hillary. The media is giving Obama a free ride and they will be sorry one day!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Fuzzy, TN — Mon, 18 Feb 2008 20:02:38 GMT

I still haven't gotten over the downward spiral in the Clinton campaign that I feel you started and continued for several weeks on your show with your constant bashing of Hillary. This negativity that you began may cause her to lose the election. What a shame! Also, as far as I'm concerned, Morning Joe should go to a Fox network where he should feel right at home with Bill Boy O'Reilly. Don't change a thing on "Countdown" - good job.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

DAlnB, Fallon, NV — Mon, 18 Feb 2008 23:57:49 GMT

Comments or suggestion that Hillary Clinton is a politician is 110% correct; suggesting she is a good politician is quite the opposite. The difference is a person (like Hillary) who has spent the years she has in and around Washington but has little show for it; particularly things with a national impact. A good politician is one who puts the interest of the nation first. Hillary does not fit into the last category. She claims to have "many good ideas and opportunities for America" but with her 15 years in Washington, as the first lady and as senator, she has not brought these out. She has been a part of the mess in Washington that has all but ruined our economy and quality of life.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Rebecca Goff-McDavis — Tue, 19 Feb 2008 20:42:51 GMT

I find it interesting how Hillary keeps taking cheap shots at Obama's character. If he wanted to play dirty politics he could bring up the fact that Hillary sat on Tara Bank's show and told the nation's young women that there was never a doubt in her mind Bill loved her even though he cheated on her over and over again. What is that telling them?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Phyllis, Scottsdale, AZ — Tue, 19 Feb 2008 23:57:42 GMT

Chris, don't disappoint those of us that dislike dirty politics. Keep fighting for us and don't cave in to the Clinton's. We're having to experience the ugliness of what they are capable of every time they're behind in the polls. And, make no mistake, it is the "Clinton's" who are clawing their way to the nomination anyway they can. In New Hampshire it was the emotional breakdown and, now, in Wisconsin it's accusing Obama of stealing everyone elses words. Which is ironic when you go back and track their campaign since the beginning. They have changed slogans and used any verbage that was working for other candidates in that moment.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Laura, Richmond, VA — Wed, 20 Feb 2008 04:18:39 GMT

Chris:

I'm a huge fan! For better or worse, and when I don't always agree with you, I'm still a fan.

I really wanted to commend you for your questioning this evening in the primary coverage for Wisconsin. You interviewed a Rep. from Ohio who is for Clinton and a Dem. from TX. that is for Obama. The Rep. from Ohio was spot on in her endorsement of Clinton and spoke well to all the specifics of the Clinton platform. The Dem. from Tx. was dreadful in backing Obama. Thanks so much for staying with it and insisting that this guy tell us what legislative successes Obama has accomplished - he couldn't recall any. You Rock! Keep playin' Hardball!!!

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Jim, Sacramento, California — Wed, 20 Feb 2008 04:36:49 GMT

Wow, Chris, what a great question tonight to the Obama supporter about what legislative success he has had! The response was great: silence. My criticism is that you missed a great opportunity to ask the very same question of the Clinton supporter. The response would have been the same. I've been waiting for a year for that question to be put to the Clinton camp, but you media people never ask it. I'm really tired of hearing about Clinton's "experience". Just EXACTLY what has she done to effect change on any issue she so regularly talks about? Some of us really want to know. How about some fairness here?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Virginia, Florida — Wed, 20 Feb 2008 14:21:42 GMT

Chris you are my favorite anaylist. Here's my question. You say that we should look at Obama's senate record to predict future success as a leader. Should we also consider the way both Clinton and Obama have managed the primary process? She never admits defeat and she attacks when she is down. Financially she started out with a huge lead and had to dip into her own funds to continue. Does that sound presidential? Let's look at what Hillary has failed to do in the past...healthcare ring any bells?

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Robin, CA — Wed, 20 Feb 2008 18:13:47 GMT

With Obama's success, some of the umph has gone out of my desire to vote. I am a Hillary supporter. I believe she would do the best job as President, because she has something to prove; don't all women? Obama on the other hand is a usurper, and I don't respect him at all. I will probably go for McCain. I believe the people will not be happy after all the brouhaha passes over. As for your comment about Hillary, I have decided that you are biased and sexist and I do not watch your show anymore.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

P A Vecchiarelli Agawam, MA — Wed, 20 Feb 2008 22:11:50 GMT

Chris, your treatment of a State Senator from Texas on an interview last night showed your bias for the Clintons. You let the Congress Woman from Ohio respond with a general answer on Hillary and beat the heck out of the State Senator from Texas when he was supporting Obama with a genral answer. You need to be more impartial.

Matthews: Clinton proves herself a 'great politician'

Bill P, Coachella, Calif — Thu, 21 Feb 2008 18:08:30 GMT

Why do men hate a confident and strong woman? Why are other women threatened by Hillary's achievments?

Men have ruled for 232 years and look where we are, in the abyss of destruction. I like Senator Obama and think he would make a great President, but not while we are still in a "State of Emergency." This is not the time for "on the job training." Obama is just another man trying to rule America.

Clinton DOES have the necessary experience and might to reverse 8 years of "Dark Ages" rule by Bush and stand up to rogue govt's on day 1. As a participant in former Pres. Clinton's administration, she has experienced the leadership role of Commander in Chief and can rule just as good as men.

Let's allow a "women's perspective" in governing America for a change. People will always FEAR CHANGE! It takes one to make it happen.